To say that the gap between the Romance of the Three Kingdoms and the history of the three kingdoms may scare everyone.
First of all, Liu Guanzhang did not have the Taoyuan Sanjieyi, they were just like brothers, Guan Yu was two years older than Liu Bei, his sex was like a fire, he was born as a ranger, and he was strong in martial arts. The whipping of the post inspector was not Zhang Fei's, but Liu Bei's, Liu Bei was only a lieutenant in Anxi County at that time, just when the imperial court decreed that the county-level people with military merit as the chief officials should be eliminated, Liu Bei just happened to be among the eliminated, just at this time, the overseer in charge of the elimination work arrived, Liu Bei went to see him, presumably to let Shangguan be accommodating, but the governor said that he was sick and did not see, Liu Bei ate a closed door soup. Therefore, Liu Bei was furious, led someone to tie up the governor, beat him with two hundred lashes, and abandoned the official. Romance of the Three Kingdoms. The Biography of the First Lord records the process of Liu Bei's murder: "The First Lord led his subordinate lieutenant Zou Jing to beg the Yellow Turban Thief for meritorious service, except for Lieutenant An Xi. When the overseer went to the county on official business, he first asked for advice from the Lord, but he did not pass, and went straight into the postmaster, and the staff was two hundred, and the silk was tied to his neck and the horse willow, and he abandoned the official and died."
Whipping the Overseer
In the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, the two armies are opposed, and there are often scenes in which the two armies will directly single out, and hundreds of rounds of great battles will be fought, and people's blood will boil. But in the main history, the chance of going out to single out is very small, think about it, wearing dozens of pounds of armor, holding dozens of pounds of weapons, riding a horse, not to mention the hundreds of rounds of the war, that is, a few hundred times, it is enough, and whether the war horse can withstand it is another matter. In the main history, there are even fewer deeds of beheading enemy generals in thousands of armies and horses, but here it has to be said that Guan Yu, Guan Erye, people are really bullish, And Guan Yu's ten thousand armies have beheaded Yan Liang from it, but it is clearly recorded in the main history. Romance of the Three Kingdoms. The biography of Guan Yu records: "Yu saw liangqi gai, and the spur of the horse was good among the multitudes, and beheaded it, and the generals of Shao zhu could not be the one who could do it, so they lifted the siege of the white horse."
However, the famous story of Wenjiu beheading Huaxiong does not exist, and in the history of Zhengyi, Huaxiong was killed by Sun Jian. And the scene of the three Heroes Fighting Lü Bu that made Liu Guanzhang famous in the world also did not exist, because the history books record that there was no Gongsun Zhan who participated in the crusade against Dong Zhuo, and at this time Liu Guanzhang was under Gongsun Zhang.com. Guan Yu and Guan Ping are biological father and son, not Guan Ping as mentioned in the rendition as Guan Ping's righteous son.
Zhou Cang, who carried a large knife for Guan Yu, could not find this person, of course, Guan Erye's weapon Qinglong Yanyue Knife also did not exist, because according to the literature and excavated cultural relics, the Yanyue knife only began to appear in the Song Dynasty, combined with the record of the "Romance of the Three Kingdoms": "Yu Wang saw Liang Li Gai, the spur was good among the people, and beheaded him," Guan Yu killed Yan Liang, and successively used the two actions of "stabbing" and "chopping", which can be speculated that Guan Yu most likely used a straight stab weapon such as a spear or a halberd, plus a close defense weapon such as a single knife, in order to be able to" Beheading it also", because the single knife was indeed a very popular weapon at the time. Not only that, according to the examination of the development and use of weapons, the big knives of Huang Zhong and Wei Yan, the big axes of Xu Huang, and the Fang Tian paintings of Lü Bu in the novel are also fictional.
Also known as one of the four great beauties of ancient times, the mink cicada is also invented in the novel, the prototype is one of Dong Zhuo's maids, Lü Bu is precisely because of this maid fornication, afraid of being discovered by Dong Zhuo, only to be pulled by Wang Yun to take the opportunity to murder Dong Zhuo. And Lü Bu did not recognize Ding Yuan Dong Zhuo as his father, he and Dong Zhuo only swore as father and son, there is no three surname family slaves, but Lü Bu's job-hopping means are indeed very unusual, others jump ship at most scold the boss a few words, and Lü Bu is directly kill the boss first and then leave.
Film and television drama mink cicada
In the rendition, Zhuge Liang was a fledgling man, strategizing, burning Bowangpo, burning Xiahou Huan's remnants of the army and returning to Xuchang in a terrible state, completing an excellent battle, and at the same time changing Guan Yu and Zhang Fei's views on Zhuge Liang, both admiring him. However, in the main history, the Battle of Bowangpo had nothing to do with Zhuge Liang, and the real commander of this battle was Liu Bei, and At this time, Zhuge Liang was still living in seclusion in Longzhong and had not yet come out of the mountain. Romance of the Three Kingdoms. The Biography of the First Lord records: "To reject Xiahou Huan and yu ban is equal to Bo Wang." For a long time, the lord set up an ambush, and once he burned himself, he chased after it and was broken by the ambush."
In the speech, Zhuge Liang said that Wei Yan had a backbone behind his head and had been guarding against Wei Yan, which was also false. The History records that Liu Bei attacked Hanzhong, and Wei Yanba became the general of Zhenyuan and the Taishou of Hanzhong, becoming a general who was on his own side, and Zhen defended Hanzhong for more than ten years. After Liu Bei ascended the throne, the general Bai Zhenbei was very highly valued, zhuge Liang was also very useful to Wei Yan, and the Meridian Valley plot was not adopted, also because Zhuge was cautious in using troops and never took risks. As for the will, it was even more nonsense for Ma Dai to kill him from behind. The empty city plan is not Zhuge Liang's, the prototype is Cao Cao's empty city plan for Lü Bu, Zhao Yun also cleverly set up an empty camp, "scare" Cao Cao who was full of strategy, at this time there was Liu Bei's evaluation of Zhao Yun: "Zilong is all guts!" The main opponent of Zhuge Liang's Northern Expedition was not Sima Yi, but Cao Zhen and Zhang Guo, Sima Yi was more on the front line of defending Eastern Wu, Zhuge Liang fought with Sima Yi twice, and the second time was not over, and he had already died of illness.
Zhang Fei's roar when Yangqiao was true, Zhao Yuncao's seven in and seven outs were fabricated, and the straw boat borrowing arrows was done by Sun Quan, and it did not occur at the time of the Battle of Chibi, but in the Battle of Wusukou five years later, at this time there was Cao Cao's sentence: "When a son is born, it should be like Sun Zhongmou." At the time of the Battle of Chibi, Cao Cao's actual number was more than 200,000, and there was no claimed army of 800,000, while Sun Liu's coalition army was only 50,000 people, of which Sun Quan was 30,000 and Liu Bei was 20,000. Cao Jun was not all killed by fire, but more because the army was infected with the plague, it was fatal. As for the interpretation of The Chinese Rong Dao Guan Yu Yi Interpretation of Cao Cao, it also does not exist. Romance of the Three Kingdoms. It is recorded in the Biography of the Ancestors: "Quan dispatched tens of thousands of sailors such as Zhou Yu and Cheng Pu to join forces with the Ancestors and fought with Cao Gong at Chibi, destroyed them, and burned their boats and ships." The first lord and the Wu army marched side by land and water, and pursued them to Nan County, where there were diseases from time to time, and the northern army died many deaths, and Cao Gong was led back."
The Battle of Yiling, one of the "three major battles" of the Three Kingdoms, was not a battle in which less won more, Liu Bei claimed to have an army of 700,000, but in fact it was more than 40,000, while Lu Xun had more than 50,000 soldiers and horses, more than Liu Bei's soldiers. Zhou Yu was not killed by anger, but on the way to the march. Infected with diseases, not to die of illness. Zhou Yu was elegant, both literary and martial, and had great talent, and there was no record of meeting zhuge Liang in the main history, and in historical history, the contact between Eastern Wu and Liu Bei had always been Lu Su and Zhuge Jin, and Zhuge Liang had only visited Jiangdong once to promote Sun Liu's alliance, and Zhou Yu was not present at that time.
Film and television drama Zhou Yu
There are still many differences from historical facts in the speech, unexpectedly everyone's imagination, for example, to scrape Guan Yu's bones to heal his wounds, not Hua Tuo, at this time Hua Tuo has been dead for more than ten years; the red rabbit horse is also exclusive to Lü Bu, Guan Yu has never ridden; the White Emperor City entrusted the orphan, not only to Zhuge Liang, but to Zhuge Liang and Shang Shu Ling Li Yan, many stories that everyone is familiar with, but the real situation is unbelievable.
The difference between "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" and the main history is very large, and it can only be said that "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" is written too wonderfully and has too deep an impact on us, so that we can better understand the real story that happened during the Three Kingdoms period!