■ Wen | Jinlun
Hongmao Medicinal Liquor, which has been silent for a while, has recently succeeded in pushing itself into the air of public opinion. Unlike the last time it was "concerned", Hongmao's focus on public opinion this time is no longer because of the negative company, but a great thing - winning the award, yes, you read it right, Hongmao medicinal liquor won the award.
According to media reports, on December 21, at the "2019 China Traditional Chinese Medicine Innovation and Development Forum and the Press Conference of china's Corporate Social Responsibility Report on Chinese Medicines" sponsored by the China Association of Chinese Medicines, Hongmao Pharmaceutical was awarded the honorary title of "2018 Star Enterprise for Fulfilling Social Responsibility", and Bao Dongqi, vice president of Hongmao Pharmaceutical, won the 2018 Annual Person award for Fulfilling Social Responsibility.
In 2018, Hongmao Medicinal Liquor fulfilled its social responsibilities, I am not impressed. However, there is one thing I remember very clearly:
In December 2017, Guangdong doctor Tan Qindong published an article online questioning the efficacy of Hongmao medicinal liquor. On January 10, 2018, the Public Security Bureau of Liangcheng County, Inner Mongolia, arrested Tan Qindong across provinces on suspicion of "harming goodwill."
After a turnaround, the Ministry of Public Security and the Inner Mongolia procuratorate spoke out one after another, and Tan Qindong left the Liangcheng County Detention Center on April 17 due to unclear facts and insufficient evidence due to unclear facts and insufficient evidence.
At that time, the public opinion clearly showed that the evaluation of Hongmao medicinal liquor was a negative, was it because this matter fulfilled its social responsibility, so it won the award? In these years, the police were called to the police, and the police were arrested across provinces, and then the people were released "because the facts were unclear and the evidence was insufficient", which was also considered to be a fulfillment of social responsibility?
I happen to have been involved in texts like CSR reports, and I know some basic criteria, such as at least charity activities, donations, and a certain level.
I went to the official website of Hongmao Pharmaceutical to check, under the two columns of "Hongmao News" and "Media Focus", in the time interval of 2018 (pay attention to this premise), I really did not see any information about charitable donations. Searching for the past records of Hongmao Medicinal Liquor, the company has indeed participated in some charity activities and has also donated money.
For example, media reports: On May 31, the 2019 National Wisdom Health Care Conference was held in Beijing. As an invited enterprise, Bao Dongqi, vice president of Inner Mongolia Hongmao Pharmaceutical Co., Ltd., attended the conference, and Bao Dongqi introduced that Hongmao Pharmaceutical supports public welfare undertakings and helps alleviate poverty. Over the years, Hongmao Pharmaceutical has donated nearly 10 million yuan in social welfare activities such as earthquake relief, caring for the poor elderly, and funding poor students.
However, this is a unilateral statement, I still want to look at the data of 2018, can the Chinese Medicine Association show it? Be sure to authoritatively channel the data, including donation receipts, records, quotas, etc.
"Hongmao medicinal liquor has not yet exterminated the leopard clan?"
The matter of social responsibility also involves whether it is a compliant and legal operation enterprise.
The formula of Hongmao medicinal liquor has leopard bones, and each serving is 15g. "Panther bones are fried in five times water for 10 hours to run out of glue. The decoction is strained, the filtrate is concentrated to a thick paste, let cool and set aside". To brew 187 kilograms of medicinal liquor, it is necessary to use 160 kilograms of white wine, 45 kilograms of brown sugar, 15 kilograms of rock sugar, and 2 kilograms of red yeast. Among the remaining herbs, the ingredients for 12 herbs range from 30g to 240g, and the 55 herbs are 15g per variety.
How much leopard bone is needed to spread the dose of 15 grams of leopard bone per serving into 374 bottles of wine?
According to industrial and commercial information, since November 2007, the construction scale of Inner Mongolia Hongmao Sinopharm Co., Ltd., a subsidiary of Hongmao Medicinal Liquor, has reached an annual output of 15,000 tons of medicinal liquor. Hongmao medicinal liquor requires 1203 kg of leopard bone per year. According to the data, each leopard has only a few kilograms of bones, which means that hundreds of adult leopards are needed every year to meet the production of Hongmao medicinal liquor.
According to the data released by the Ministry of Forestry, there are only 3310 in China.
Really use leopard bones, within a few years, Hongmao medicinal liquor will exterminate the leopards in our country, and it is illegal, leopards are national first-level protected animals.
So, the question is, is there any leopard bone in Hongmao medicinal liquor? If not, it is naturally not illegal, but it involves deceiving consumers and false advertising, and there must be a statement on this matter.
Can the Chinese Medicine Association stand up and respond: how did a company that either killed leopards or deceived consumers get the title of "Star Enterprise for Fulfilling Social Responsibilities" issued by your association?
Moreover, since 2008, the Food and Drug Administration of Jiangsu, Zhejiang, Hainan and other provinces has issued several public announcements, requiring the sale and advertising of Hongmao medicinal liquor to be stopped.
For many years, the Zhejiang Provincial Food and Drug Administration has listed the Advertisement of Hongmao Medicinal Liquor as an advertisement for illegal drugs and issued a notice, holding that the Advertisement of Hongmao Medicinal Liquor "exaggerates the indications of the product, the indications of function, or contains assertions and guarantees that unscientifically express efficacy; contains other content that seriously deceives and misleads consumers" and "uses the name and image of medical research units, academic institutions, experts, scholars, doctors, patients, etc. to prove it".
Have these issues been rectified in 2018? Otherwise, why "fulfill social responsibility"?
Interestingly, when the media asked whether there were any standards to follow for Hongmao medicinal liquor to win the award, a staff member of the China Association of Chinese Medicines responded that there must be standards and a basis for evaluation, but it is not convenient to disclose.
The above-mentioned staff stressed: "This is a matter within our industry". In addition, he said, "The past is the past, and we judge the present and the future of the company." Don't stare at people's past, we encourage this kind of dishonesty in the past but now honesty. ”
The staff obviously has no basic common sense, this "social responsibility star enterprise" title is for the company's 2018 behavior, the full name is "2018 annual social responsibility star enterprise" honorary title, must say the past, how can we prevaricate the media with "the past is the past, we are evaluating the present and the company's future"?
No professionalism at all.
The staff also educated the media, "Don't stare at the past of others, we will encourage this kind of dishonesty in the past but now honest (company)", which is simply a slippery slope, then the honorary title issued by the Chinese Medicine Association should be changed to "The future will fulfill social responsibility star enterprises" is not ok, directly blocking the mouth of the media.
As for saying "this is a matter within our industry", this is even more fearless for the ignorant, and a Chinese medicine association with a Chinese name awarded the title of "Star Enterprise fulfilling social responsibility" to a medicinal distillery that may have used leopard bone (or useless) is it really a matter in the industry?
Isn't he using his own name to bless the company? Is it possible for enterprises to use this name to do publicity and promotion, and obtain corporate reputation and sales?
These things are not within the industry, but major events related to the people's wallet and corporate image.
"Can you also win awards by digging holes for investors?"
Next, I would like to leave aside Hongmao Medicinal Liquor and talk about the Chinese Medicine Association and its honorary title of "Star Enterprise for Fulfilling Social Responsibility".
The relevant news of the Beijing News shows:
According to public information, the Association of Chinese Medicines was established in 2000, registered with the Ministry of Civil Affairs, with 34 branches, each of which can develop its own members, and its membership is managed by the Association of Chinese Medicines.
As of December 24, the Association of Chinese Medicines had a total of 385 corporate members. Hongmao Pharmaceutical, which was awarded the "2018 Star Enterprise for Fulfilling Social Responsibility", is a member unit of the Chinese Medicine Association with an annual membership fee of 5,000 yuan.
According to the official website of the Ministry of Civil Affairs, the registration date of the establishment of the Chinese Medicine Association in the Ministry of Civil Affairs is December 18, 2000, and it has existed for 19 years, with a registered capital of 500,000 yuan and the legal representative is Wu Xian.
The "Interim Measures for Member Management" also discloses the classification of members, which are vice president units, director units and member units, respectively, and the corresponding annual fees are 30,000 yuan, 10,000 yuan and 5,000 yuan respectively.
As of December 24, the Chinese Medicine Association has a total of 385 corporate members, including 65 vice president units, 55 council units and 265 member units, if calculated according to this calculation, the Chinese Medicine Association can receive up to 3.825 million yuan in membership fees in 2019.
It was all silver.
What is even more interesting is that Buchang, Kangmei and Sunflower were all awarded the "2018 Annual Star Enterprises for Fulfilling Social Responsibility" by the Chinese Medicine Association.
Danhong Injection, the core exclusive variety of Buchang Pharmaceutical, has been repeatedly exposed by the media to have adverse reactions, and has appeared many times on the monitoring list of the Health and Family Planning Commission or the top three hospitals in Anhui, Inner Mongolia, Henan, Qinghai, Suzhou, Harbin, Luoyang and other provinces and cities, and has been monitored or restricted from use (The Paper).
As for Kangmei Pharmaceutical, it is a well-known fraud company: in April this year, Kangmei Pharmaceutical released its 2018 annual report at the same time as issuing an accounting error correction instruction. According to the CSRC's investigation, Kangmei Pharmaceutical inflated its operating income by 8.999 billion yuan, 10.032 billion yuan, 8.484 billion yuan and 1.613 billion yuan in its semi-annual reports in 2016, 2017, 2018 semi-annual reports and 2018 annual reports, and inflated operating profits by 656 million yuan, 1.251 billion yuan, 2.029 billion yuan and 165 million yuan, accumulated inflated operating income by 29.128 billion yuan, and accumulated inflated operating profits by 3.936 billion yuan.
Note that Kangmei in "2018" is such a pit for investors to dig a hole in the enterprise, the result of the Chinese Medicine Association said, it is you, you are "2018 annual social responsibility star enterprise"!
This is the so-called industry standard that the Chinese Medicine Association is inconvenient to disclose? Who digs a pit for investors, who is a "star enterprise that fulfills social responsibility"? Why does this make the SFC feel bad? I punish, you give a prize, what does it mean?
Let's talk about Sunflower Pharmaceuticals. On July 6, 2018, the State Drug Administration (CFDA) issued the Notice on 31 Batches of Drugs Not Complying with regulations (No. 53 [2018]). Sunflower Pharmaceutical Group (Jilin) Linjiang Co., Ltd. (hereinafter referred to as "Sunflower Linjiang"), a subsidiary of Sunflower Pharmaceutical, has 4 batches of products yanligu capsules that do not meet the regulations.
On January 16, 2018, Beijing Business Daily reported on the news that "Sunflower Pharmaceutical's subsidiaries Hengshui Jizhou Sunflower and Hengshui Defil Sunflower were named seven times by the Hengshui Municipal Food and Drug Administration and ordered to make corrections" under the title of "Why Sunflower Pharmaceutical Has Repeatedly Been On the Black List".
What is even more appalling is that on December 22, 2018, Guan Yanbin, then chairman of Sunflower Pharmaceutical, held a kitchen knife at the home of his ex-wife Zhang Xiaolan's parents and slashed Zhang Xiaolan 4 times; after the murder, Guan Yanbin also tried to raise a knife and kill himself. On June 28, 2019, the procuratorate filed a public prosecution with the court against Guan Yanbin, the former chairman of Sunflower Pharmaceutical.
Note that the time of this case is "December 22, 2018", which means that although you hacked your ex-wife, your business can still be a "socially responsible star enterprise".
The Chinese Medicine Association is so rigid, awesome!
"It is recommended that the Chinese Medicine Association compile a special dictionary"
I think, is there any misunderstanding of the term "social responsibility" by the Chinese Medicine Association?
Social responsibility is a positive word, not a negative word. It should not be associated with words such as "adverse reaction", "fraud", "blacklist", "slashing and killing ex-wives", and should your association redefine "social responsibility"?
In this way, I solemnly suggest that your association raise millions of dollars from its members, no, ten million, re-compile a "Special Dictionary for Chinese Medicine Associations", and change the word "social responsibility".
Now one interpretation of the word is that "social responsibility refers to the responsibility of an organization to society", and I think your association can change it to "social responsibility refers to the responsibility that an organization should not bear to the society, and can have financial fraud, wife killing cases and adverse reactions in the use of products".
Perfect or not? Surprise or no surprise?
It's an absurd world. By the way, I still implore your association to announce the selection criteria for "enterprises that fulfill social responsibility" as soon as possible, I believe it must be very exciting, and it will definitely be the first in the hot search.
In addition, when the surging news reporter called the contact person of the organizing committee of the aforementioned conference in the name of the pharmaceutical company on December 24 to consult how to participate in next year's award, the other party said that it was necessary to understand the size of the enterprise before informing whether it was eligible to participate in the competition.
When the reporter asked whether the award needed to be paid, the other party said: "You tell me which company it is first, and then I will tell you whether to receive it or not, and you don't say don't talk to me." ”
In fact, if it is an authoritative and credible award, it should be said with a straight face: "We do not charge money, it is a public welfare act, in order to promote the healthy development of the industry."
The contact actually wants the other party to tell which company to tell first, and then tell the other party whether to receive it, I really blush for you, is your conscience not painful? What about discipline? What else to say "tell you whether to receive or not", you should ask yourself a sentence of "low not low"?
Finally, a knife: In accordance with the corresponding regulations and the charter formulated, the Chinese Medicine Association shall publish the income and expenditure situation, acceptance of donations and other information every year.
We have worked hard to search carefully for a long time, and have not found it, please ask the Chinese Medicine Association to disclose it.