"I am a singer" is a competitive platform, the singer's singing skills is the most important measure, therefore, some more literary, strong personality style singers on the stage of "I am a singer", often easy to "suffer losses". In the eighth episode of "Singer 2019", the re-enactment singer Yang Naiwen, who had just participated in two episodes of the program, ranked seventh, and the "one round tour" was eliminated.
Yang Naiwen is a small singer in Taiwan, whose musical style is mainly British rock, and is loved by fans to call "Music Lady". Judging from her literary and artistic song type and cold personality, Yang Naiwen is indeed unlikely to become popular.
Although niche, she is definitely not a "nameless person". After pressing down on Karen Mok, Faye Wong, and Zhang Huimei in the glory period, after winning the golden song, this achievement can be put on the body of any female singer, which can blow for most of her life. But Yang Naiwen may be the "most miserable" and unpopular golden song queen in history, and the audience that knows her well is pitiful.
Yang Naiwen on the stage of "Singer 2019", which was expected to increase her popularity in the mainland and get the audience reputation that matched her musical level, but she did not expect to be tragically "a round of travel", and many audiences did not fully understand who she was, and they could not see her on this stage. Yang Naiwen's "tragic" experience is really painful.
As soon as the news of Yang Naiwen's elimination came out, it immediately caused a lot of controversy. After two episodes of the program, she gained a lot of fans, and many audience friends in front of the TV set were also very satisfied with Yang Naiwen's "Journey in the Waves" and expressed their confusion about Yang Naiwen's elimination at the bottom.
Seven years later, the status of "I Am a Singer" as the top music variety show in the mainland is undisputed. For a long time, the most attractive point of its audience has been its strong competitiveness. Although the excessive emphasis on singing skills has a certain misleading effect on the audience, aggravating the phenomenon that the mainland only attaches importance to soaring high pitches, its judgment of the singer's singing level is still relatively scientific.
However, this is not an authentic singing competition after all, but a variety show. Even reality shows have scripts, not to mention such controversial competitive shows. The singer's whereabouts on this stage, the audience in front of the TV set is not counted, all decided by the live judges found by the program team. The musical literacy of these live judges is even more difficult for the 500 public judges to gather together.
And since the launch of "Singer 2019", the voting results of the public judges have been frequently questioned. Liu Huan and Qi Yu are undoubtedly national treasure-level singers, and their performance is also outstanding, but the ranking basically belongs to the lower middle position, and the elimination of Yang Naiwen this time is equally puzzling, and some viewers directly opened their minds and questioned whether the on-site public judges are "deaf descendants".
Judging from the music awards, there is also a female singer of the golden song level who has appeared on the stage of "I Am a Singer", she is Lin Yilian. In addition, Li Wei has been nominated for two Golden Melody Awards, and still enjoys the treatment of Lin Yilian and wins the "Song King" of the season.
Taiwanese female singers Peng Jiahui and Xu Jiaying, who also got the golden song, were not so miserable. Peng Jiahui participated as a replacement singer and was promoted. And Xu Jiaying is the starting singer, and finally reached the finals. In contrast, Yang Naiwen's "one round trip" after a golden song is really unacceptable. After all, the 500 public judges on the scene will not have the professionalism of the Golden Melody Award judges, and their judgment of Yang Naiwen will undoubtedly put this group on the opposite side of the Golden Melody Award.
However, there are on-site judges who argue that "Singer" is recorded after all, and there are more serious post-retouchings, and the effect heard on the spot and heard in front of the TV set is different. This is also the reason why the live ranking is different from the ranking in the audience's mind. Whether this is an excuse or a statement of events, we have no way of knowing. At least, Yang Naiwen's musical literacy is not controversial. Returning from the ninth installment, we continue to look forward to her wonderful performance.