The most famous, traditional and formal Water Margin film and television dramas are nothing more than three versions: The Shandong version of Water Margin, the CCTV version of Water Margin, and the new version of Water Margin. The new version of Water Margin is the worst of the three editions, and there is little merit. Let me analyze how indiscriminate it is for you in several aspects!
< h1 class="pgc-h-arrow-right" > casting failures</h1>
The important person in the original work of the Water Margin is the 108 generals, and the important figures of the 108 generals are nothing more than Song Jiang, Wu Yong, Gongsun Sheng, Li Kui, Wu Song, Lu Zhishen, Lin Chong, and Yang Zhi. None of these important characters in the new version of Water Margin conforms to the original work. Zhang Hanyu's Song Jiang was tall and mighty, with a leadership temperament, but not much cunning. First of all, the appearance is not in line with the original work, Song Jiang is a black short fat man, Zhang Hanyu is neither black, nor short, not fat, the appearance does not conform, nothing needs to be said, Song Jiang also has a characteristic city government deep, Zhang Hanyu's Song Jiang feels that the city government is insufficient. Li Zonghan's Wu use appearance is in line with the original white beard, but it feels very paralyzed, upright acting, not like the countryside pedantic, and feels too young, Wu Yong is no longer good, many people are also called brothers, at least the age will not be too small. Therefore, this version of Wu Yong was undoubtedly unsuccessful, plus taking a fan and thinking of himself as Zhuge Liang. Kang Kai's Li Kui is even more of a failure, Kang Kai has played Feng Yuxiang, Zhang Fei, Niu Gao, Li Kui, Fan Duo, etc. into a person, all like fools, laughing at every turn, there are dimples on both sides, and it is not black and feels quite white!
Chen Long's Wu Song is also a failure, thin and small, like the Shandong good man known as the Wu Song of the Heavenly Man? And it looks like Pirates of the Caribbean. Jinsong's Lu Zhishen is undoubtedly a big fool, and the appearance does not conform to Lu Zhishen, Lu Zhishen is tall and fat, Jinsong has a body of muscles, but it is not a muscle of actual combat, and Jinsong is too thin, and the brain shell is too small, and does not have Lu Zhishen's head. There is also Jin Song who speaks contrived, and he can't move at all, haha, a smirk! Hu Dong's Lin Chong is also a failure, Hu Dong's Lin Chong is really ugly and a little hateful, a bitter and vengeful look, just like how much money others owe him! The new version of Yang Zhi of Water Margin has a high and cold face, Yang Zhi is not high and cold, and this version of Yang Zhi wears a headscarf from head to tail, like a big aunt. As for others such as Gongsun Sheng like a charlatan, the winged tiger Lei Heng became a stutter! The hairdressed Duke Zhu Tong does not have a little temperament, Hu Yanzhuo is like a chef, and there is a tuft of white beard, which is very incompatible. The red-haired ghost Liu Tang is really a bit stupid, the rest of the water army leaders are small fresh meat, there is no temperament and figure of the jianghu people, Hu Ke's Gu Sister-in-law is too good-looking, the figure is too thin, not like a big worm, but like a Zhangqing, Yang Zi played by Song Huizong flowing like a rogue, not like the style of calligraphy and painting, the eunuch Tong Guan also has a face of beard, huh. Although Wang Jianxin's Lu Junyi was tall, his appearance was too ugly to meet the title of Jade Qilin . Gan Tingting's Pan Jinlian does not like to cheat, this drama on the surface 108 will have, but like the CCTV version of water margin, many good men did not appear, just showed their faces when they were seated, I don't know where to find the extras, ugly and stupid.
< h1 class="pgc-h-arrow-right" > failed</h1>
This version of the shape is too failed, Song Wan's pot lid head, DaiZong's Khitan hairstyle, Song Jiang's forehead since there is a pattern in the middle, like three eyes, there are many shapes of the cape emitted. Although it is a thief, the ancients paid great attention to the shape, and generally did not wear a shawl.
<h1 class= "pgc-h-arrow-right" > the original book is not common sense. </h1>
In this paragraph, I must explain in detail what is unreasonable to analyze what I am talking about.
The first Song Jiang distributed himself
In the original work, Song Jiang was found out by Yan Po, who was raised by him, because he had contacts with Liangshan. Yan Poxi, because of his adultery with the little white-faced Zhang Wenyuan, threatened this matter, and Song Jiang killed the slut in a rage and fled all the way back to his hometown of Song Jiazhuang. Zhixian Shi Wenbin was bent on saving Song Jiang, but Zhang Wenyuan had no choice but to provoke Yan Po to make a big fuss in Yuncheng County and threaten to file a lawsuit, and Shi Wenbin knew that he was in a loss and had to act according to the rules. Thanks to the secret help of his colleagues Zhu Tong and Lei Heng, he fled Yuncheng and fled elsewhere. The assassination of Jiangzhou only happened in the later chapters, when Yan Po had died, and without the bitter lord, Song Jiang's capital crime could be reduced to the crime of flowing.
This new version of the Water Margin has some Zhang Guan Li dai, the thorn with Jiangzhou measured a lot in advance, and the crime of murder has become a crime of flow.
If this is the case alone, it can be said that it is because song Jiang is popular and has silver. However, he also arranged for no one to escort Song Jiang, causing Song Jiang to stay idle at home all the time. This is a bit unreasonable, Yan Po is not a dead person, his girlfriend was killed, just watch the murderer so idle? What happened to Zhang Xiaosan? What do the people of Yuncheng think? What does Sangfeng Jeju Province in Yuncheng County think?
What's worse is that Song Jiang saw that there was no one to escort him, and decided to take his brother Song Qing to distribute himself, and he also said that he obeyed the law and obeyed the law.
Our beloved Song Oshi, are you the law-abiding man? You have to obey the law, how does Chao Gai run? You have to obey the law, passing through Qingfeng Mountain, you have already been cut off by Wang Xiaohu's dead fat man and made into a sour and spicy soup! If you obey the law and abide by the law, it is estimated that you can taste what the "plate knife noodles" are on the Xunyang River! You must obey the law, who in those green forests on the rivers and lakes would dare to come to you? No one has defected to you, where did your nickname for Timely Rain come from? Could it be that your father, Mrs. Song, gave it to you?
This plot is really contradictory and unreasonable!
The second mother is sorry to be a matchmaker, Song Jiang sleeping sister
This paragraph, the destruction is really called "wonderful"! It was dizzying and unexpected.
This Yan Po Pity, originally a wandering woman like Pan Jinlian, actually changed her into the "first strange woman in the ancient world" who was her own matchmaker in this drama.
I didn't know where this "strange woman" woman had so much ability, and she actually boiled half of Yuncheng County in this matter, and Zhu Tong and Lei Heng were both heads and even the county grandmaster Shi Wenbin was enough for her to give face, and they all rushed to block Song Jiang's door, just to complete this marriage.
This is not Yan PoXi, this is the "female pioneer" who resisted the "feudal oppression" and the "female middle man" who can play Yuncheng County. According to this ability of Yan Boxi in the play, in Yuncheng County, I am afraid that in addition to the county commander Shi Wenbin and The Oshi Song Jiang, you can basically sit in the third chair.
Song Jiang was even more desperate, saying during the day that in order to save Yan Po's name, he wanted to marry his brothers and sisters with Yan Po, and also called for both of them to prove it. In front of the two heads, they burned incense and bowed down, and their brother and sister did not seek the same life, but asked for the same death for half a day. After drinking in the evening, I went to my "sister", and I also said that I passed by here to visit my "sister".
But the two glasses of wine just got down the stomach "brother and sister" lay down on a bed, Yan Po Xi blew out the candle with a big mouth and the two slept together.
Is this Song Jiang who sleeps "sister" the well-known Xiaoyi Kurosaburo? Don't say that in that era, even if you put it in today's society, sleeping with your own sister will inevitably be discussed, right?
Out of such a file, what does the county grandfather think? What did Zhu Tong and Lei Heng think? What do the chickens, ducks and geese in the house think? How did Song Baosi still mix in the rivers and lakes in the future? It was good not to be scolded to death, even if he went to Liangshan as the lord of the general jurisdiction.
Again, the classic can be changed, but it is not right to change it.
The third mother night fork is a prostitute
This episode is really scorched and steaming!
Sun Erniang in the original work is the daughter of Sun Yuan, nicknamed The Fork of the Mountain Night, and Sun Yuan is a famous predecessor in the green forest.
Zhang Qing, a vegetable gardener, blocked the road and robbed the road at the cross slope of the big tree, and after fighting with Sun Yuan for twenty rounds, he fell to the ground with a flat shoulder.
Sun Yuan saw that he was flexible, so he took him back to the city, taught him skills, and married his daughter Sun Erniang to him. Sun Erniang's skills are also all taught by this Sun Yuan.
After Sun Yuan's death, the couple came to open a black shop in this cross slope.
But look at the plot of this new version of Water Margin, Sun Yuan suddenly became Sun Father, kindly took in four fallen martial artists, but was killed by their revenge, and Sun Erniang was also arranged for them to gang rape. Being gang-raped was enough, and he also sold her to the Qinglou as a prostitute, and this Sun Erniang was also too miserable.
"Big tree cross slope, guests who dare to go there!" How did a well-known green forest woman in the jianghu become a lamb to be slaughtered and a prostitute in the Qinglou?
This is not Sun Erniang, give her a treasure chest, this is Du Shiniang!
Thanks to the fact that this drama cannot be sold abroad, if it is sold abroad, it is seen by foreigners who are not familiar with water margins, and the mother night fork Sun Erniang is afraid to become the "Angolan North Nose" Sun Erniang!
Fourth, Shi Jin went to the grave
In the original work, Wang Jin, the leader of the 800,000 Forbidden Army in Tokyo, beat Up Gao Jin, who was still called the second year of high school, in Tokyo, so After Gao Li made a trace, he forced Wang Jin to leave with his mother. On the way, he coincidentally taught the Nine-Striped Dragon Shi Jin kung fu for half a year, and mastered the eighteen martial arts that Shi Jin taught, and then never appeared again after he separated from Shi Jin in Shijia Village, Huayin County, so this Wang Jin has always been a beautiful legend in the hearts of many Water Margin fans.
The incredible new version of Water Margin actually arranged the plot of Shi Jin to Wang Jin's tomb.
Judging from the dialogue between Shi Jin and Lu Da in the play, Wang Jin died of illness, and Wang Jin still died in front of his old mother, which can be described as a white-haired person sending a black-haired person. I don't know why the director and screenwriter arranged such an ending for the first good man who appeared in the Water Margin, which is really puzzling.
Fifth, Lu Zhi lost his soul deeply
Jin Sheng commented on The Water Margin and rated Lu Dalu Zhishen as a "superior figure", he is one of the few people with a chivalrous spirit among the good men of Liangshan, so whether it is Lu Da before shaving or Lu Zhishen after shaving, he is the best among people.
Lu Tizhi's rescue of the Jin father and daughter and the fisting of the town of Kansai are one of the most wonderful chapters in the Water Margin, and this paragraph fully shows the chivalrous spirit of Lu Tizhi's uneven road and drawing swords to help each other. He punched The Town Kansai not for his own selfish gain, but to use his fists to help the weak.
However, the new version of water margin randomly adds drama, and it is really a crime to change this paragraph. If you look at the look in Jin Cuilian's eyes, look at the lines he said to Jin Cuilian, and look at the way Lu Tizhi lost his soul when he was separated from Jin Cuilian, it is really a blind man's eyes.
A good anti-violence and peaceful Lu Tizhi has almost become a person who sees the color and is not simple for the purpose of strengthening the beauty.
Sixth, Bai sheng sha man
Huang Nigang's wisdom to take the birthday class is one of the most exciting chapters in the entire "Water Margin".
In this chapter, with the cooperation of the seven people headed by Chao Gai and wu Yong as the brain, plus Bai Sheng, the day rat, without using a knife and a shot, and without injuring a single person, this chapter used a strategy to conceal the team escorting the birthday gang headed by Yang Zhi, and successfully robbed this set of ill-gotten gains, so what stands out in this paragraph is a "wisdom" word.
On the other hand, the new version of Water Margin replaced Chao Gai and other jujube-carrying Jiangzhou carts (hand-pushed wheelbarrows) with donkey carts, and Bai Sheng's burden of picking wine was replaced by a donkey donkey, and even arranged for Bai Sheng to use a knife to sand a military jian after the event was completed.
The reason given by Bai Shengsha was also very reluctant, that is, because Bai Sheng was afraid that this Junjian would be able to recognize his appearance when he woke up. Let me ask, Bai Sheng sold wine on the Oka for a good toss, which person did not look at this mouse face? A good period of wisdom to take the birth anniversary class, the birth of the whole into the sand people to rob the birth anniversary class, really painting snakes to add foot.
Seventh Song Jiang catches the "thief"
After the Incident of The Wise Birth Anniversary, Song Jiang skillfully negotiated with the Jeju envoy He Tao, who was involved in the heavens, and Pegasus sent news to Chao Gai. This is the righteous place of Song Jiang and the highlight of Song Jiang. However, after this, there was nothing to do with Song Jiang after Chao Gai and others, and the thief used a knife and pen to be a small official.
The new version of "Water Margin" probably feels that Song Jiang's plays are still too few, so it gives Song Jiang such an opportunity to "catch thieves".
Then the problem comes, in the play, the thieves led by He Tao were all stirred up by the three ruan brothers in the water and swung into the water, but Song Jiang, who was in the same boat as He Tao, did not have it. Or is Song Jiang's water warfare skill so strong?
Moreover, the same people came to "catch thieves", the soldiers were dead, and He Tao also enjoyed the treatment of being cut off by Ruan Xiaoqi, but this Song Oshi was not only not dead or injured, not even a drop of water on his clothes, but also received the courtesy of Chao Gai and others in front of He Tao.
Is this gratitude to Song Jiang or to frame Song Jiang? I don't know how this Song Escort Division explained this problem to the relevant departments after he returned home.
This paragraph, like Bai Shengsharen, is also a pure destruction of the classics, which is superfluous. Maybe the director and screenwriter ignore the IQ of the relevant departments, or just ignore the IQ of the audience in front of the TV.
Eighth, Lin Chongfa was on the way to worship Lu Zhishen
Everyone knows that Lin Chong knew Lu Zhishen in the place of Shangxiang, and the two never competed. This version of the screenwriter is good, even if the competition is done, or is it a competition on the way to distribution? Don't forget, the official escorting Lin Chong was Dong Chao and Xue Ba. These two people had been bribed by Lu Yuhou to assassinate Lin Chong. The two of them also allowed you to worship Lu Zhishen on the way to distribution, and compete with Lu Zhishen, which is a big joke, and the screenwriter really should go back to the furnace to rebuild.
Ninth Wu used Gongsun Sheng to become a roundworm in Song Jiang's stomach
Song Jiang did not invite Lu Junyi up the mountain, but always wanted to give up his position to Lu Junyi, and said three reasons. The new version of Wu Yong of water margin, Gongsun Sheng is very godly, others did not say what you know? The two of you must be roundworms in Song Jiang's belly.
The tenth corn crossed, and Song Jiang appeared in advance
The first of the new water margin not only Song Jiang appeared in advance, but even the seven stars also appeared in advance. Since Gongsun Sheng also went to invite Song Jiang to join the company, he was still a prophet, and said that in the future, you are the king of the mountains, the Thunder People, and since you are still in the sorghum field next to you, Lei's outer JiaoLinn. Since Lei Heng Zhu Tong became Song Jiang's younger brother, Lei Heng was still a stutter, and Lei was thorough.
There is also Lin Chong for a few silver pounds of money, nonsense half a day and Lin Chong desperately, get rid of Wang Lun, but also asked Du Qian, can you really touch the sky? Ask Song Wan are you the King Kong in the clouds? Isn't this Zz? People's obvious nicknames, there must be exaggerated elements, but also to ask in detail. There is also the abbot of Mount Wutai, since he is Zhou Dong, he also teaches Lu Zhishen kung fu. Since Lu Junyi went to guard the border pass, Shi Wengong, Lin Chong, Lu Zhishen Since Lu Junyi is still a brother of the division, I am also drunk, why do many people say that they are brothers of the division today, I want to ask the original book whether there is such a thing? It's nonsense. Gao Li and others also dared to provoke Emperor Huizong's underground lover, Master Li, and I was also drunk. There is also Wu Yong who was forced to commit suicide by Yang Zhi, fortunately saved, otherwise the good man of Liangshan would have less wisdom and more stars Wu Yong [nose picking] and Lin Chong went up the mountain to blame Lu Zhishen for not taking good care of his wife, and wanted to sand him. When Wu Song and Wu Da first met, Wu Song was simply a child who had not grown up, the nonsense was too big, the action was too big, and he broke two bowls, which was completely inconsistent with Wu Song's personality. The plot of Wu Song fighting the tiger is so famous, which was also ruined by this version. Wu Song fights the tiger is obviously at night, and this version is daytime. Wu Song is a bare-handed tiger, this version of stabbing the tiger with a knife. And this version of the tiger is not real, it is made by computers. There is also Wu Song who walks Centipede Ridge at night, and this version is Walking Centipede Ridge during the day. Lin Jiaotou has the appearance of sinking fish and falling geese, and there are many childish plots of Lei Ren who do not want to give examples one by one.
Let's talk about the martial arts setting here, which is simply blowing people's hearts. Hu Yanzhuo can second Sha Qinming and Huang Xin. Since Hu Yanzhuo did not dare to fight with Third Lady Hu, zhang Qing's hat could knock Dong Ping off his horse. Since Dong Ping had beaten Xu Ning, Third Lady Hu did not need to set the horse rope, and since she could defeat Han Tao and Peng Xuan in a few rounds. Wu Song was almost countered by Ximen Qing, cut off half of his hand by Fang La, and so on.
<h1 class="pgc-h-arrow-right" > play failed</h1>
The slow motion of the new Water Margin play is too much, too fake, and the play feels soft and soft, without strength. And I like to pause when I can't move, and I am very unhappy to watch. The investment in this version is also small, and since the food on many tables is a prop, there is very little meat, and a table of green vegetables!
However, this edition also has merits, and the content is more detailed and richer than the previous two editions. The storyline is also more vivid, most of the good guys are fully acted, the images are also very high-definition, the actresses in it are also more watchable, and some war scenes are also filmed well. It is still very good to look at it as a general costume drama.