Please use your golden finger to make a fortune, like and take a walk, get rich forever, pay attention to the like, it is difficult to get rich if you don't want to
In the city of Suzhou, a shocking family dispute is unfolding, touching the hearts of countless people. Mrs. Lu, an elderly man, generously donated three sets of demolition and resettlement houses worth 2 million yuan to her granddaughter Li.
She thought that this generous gift could be exchanged for care and care in her later years, but she was sued by her granddaughter for renting out one of the houses without permission. This case not only reveals a complex story of affection, greed, and the law, but also provokes a deep reflection on the concept of filial piety in modern society.
What is the reason for the originally close relationship between grandparents and grandchildren to come to such a point? How will the law adjudicate this poignant family dispute? Let's dive into this story and find out the ins and outs.
In 2019, Suzhou's urban development plan was like a whirlwind, completely changing Mrs. Lu's peaceful life. As a native of Suzhou, Mrs. Lu and her husband have worked hard in the city, raised a pair of children, and spent most of their lives.
However, as urbanization progresses, the old houses they have lived in for many years have been included in the scope of demolition.
The demolition compensation gave Mrs. Lu three sets of resettlement houses with a total value of up to 2 million yuan, and this windfall made the old man fall into deep thought. While considering what to do with these properties, her eyes involuntarily fell on her only granddaughter, Li.
Li lost his father since he was a child and depended on his grandparents, and Mrs. Lu loved this granddaughter very much and regarded her as her own.
In order to properly arrange this property, Mrs. Lu called a family meeting. She solemnly announced her initial idea: among the three properties, one is for her daughter, one is for her daughter-in-law, and the remaining one is reserved for Li.
However, unexpectedly, the daughter and daughter-in-law declined the gift, believing that the properties should ultimately belong to Li.
In the face of such a generous attitude of her family, Mrs. Lu felt ripples in her heart. She remembered the cases that had been reported frequently in recent years and turned against her children over property issues, and she couldn't help but hesitate.
After repeated considerations, she made a seemingly thoughtful decision: to give all three properties to Li, but asked Li to take on the responsibility of taking care of his grandmother while keeping a house for herself to live in.
Under the witness of the community neighborhood committee, Mrs. Lu and Li solemnly signed the agreement and completed this seemingly perfect arrangement. However, in addition to the joy, Mrs. Lu still had a trace of uneasiness hidden in her heart.
She hopes that this gift will be exchanged for her granddaughter's sincere filial piety, but she is vaguely worried that the early transfer of property will bring unexpected consequences.
This gift of love is like a time bomb buried under the surface of the warm vein, quietly laying the foundation for future family disputes. Mrs. Lu could never have imagined that her loving decision would eventually lead to this heartbreaking family tragedy.
As the years go by, Mrs. Lu's health is getting worse and worse. She was originally full of expectations, thinking that Li would fulfill the agreement and often come to visit and take care of her.
However, the cruelty of reality ruthlessly shattered her beautiful vision.
In the early days, Li would come to visit his grandmother from time to time, help with housework, and chat with her. Mrs. Lu is full of happy smiles every time, as if she has returned to the warm time when Li was a child.
But as time went on, such visits became less frequent and more perfunctory.
Mrs. Lu often sat alone in front of the window, looking at the bustling crowd downstairs, but she felt more lonely than ever before. She began to call Li frequently, hoping to hear her granddaughter's cordial greetings.
However, there was either a cold answer on the other end of the line, or no answer at all. Every disappointed wait made Mrs. Lu's heart cool down a little bit.
She began to wonder if the decision to give the property to Li was really wise.
Fate always seems to like to joke. A sudden illness became the last straw that broke the camel's back. That day, Mrs. Lu suddenly felt a sharp pain in her chest, but fortunately she was found by a kind neighbor and sent to the hospital in time.
In the hospital room, filled with the smell of disinfectant water, she waited with anticipation for her family's arrival. However, the daughter-in-law just took a quick look and left, and Li never showed up.
This experience made Mrs. Lu completely recognize the reality. She realized that she could no longer count on Lee's care. In desperation and disappointment, she made a difficult decision: to move into a nursing home.
In the nursing home, Mrs. Lu gradually adapted to the new rhythm of life. She met some like-minded old friends, played chess, chatted, and practiced in the morning. However, in the dead of night, she still thinks of Li and the little girl who was once innocent.
She didn't understand why family affection, which was thicker than water, would be consumed by money and possessions.
During this time, Li seemed to have evaporated from the world and never appeared in his grandmother's life again. She seems to be immersed in the joy of acquiring three properties, and has long since forgotten her original promise.
And this alienation is quietly brewing an even bigger storm.
The relationship between Mrs. Lu and Li is like a crumbling bridge, which once connected two intimate hearts, but now only cold interest calculations remain.
This transition from intimacy to alienation is not only a family tragedy, but also a microcosm of society as a whole, reflecting the fragility of human relationships in a modern society where money is paramount.
With the passage of time, the high cost of the nursing home gradually became an unbearable burden for Mrs. Lu. Her meager pension could not cope with the rising cost of care, and her savings were being depleted day by day.
In this predicament, she racked her brains to come up with a solution: rent out the house she lived in and use the rent to subsidize the expenses of the nursing home.
After careful consideration, Mrs. Lu found a tenant named Wang. Based on the principle of honesty and trustworthiness, she truthfully informed Wang that the actual ownership of the house belonged to Li, and showed him the people's mediation agreement signed at the beginning.
After both parties agreed, they successfully signed the rental agreement.
However, this seemingly urgent decision was inadvertently ignited a time bomb. When Li learned that his grandmother had rented out the house without authorization, he was furious.
In her opinion, she is the "real owner" of the house, and her grandmother's behavior seriously violates her rights and interests.
Li approached Wang and verbally demanded that he hand over the rent to himself, otherwise he would be sued in court for illegal possession. However, Wang is not good at stubble, and he has studied the law quite a bit.
He calmly said that he had carefully reviewed the mediation agreement and believed that the lease contract signed with Mrs. Lu was completely legal and valid, and resolutely rejected Li's unreasonable request.
The rental dispute quickly escalated and became the fuse for the complete breakdown of the relationship between the grandparents and grandchildren. Li's greed and selfishness are exposed, while Mrs. Lu is deeply disappointed and heartbroken.
She never thought that her hard work would be treated so ruthlessly by her granddaughter.
This turmoil not only revealed the tip of the iceberg of family conflicts, but also pushed the once close grandparents and grandchildren to the opposite side of the court. It profoundly reflects that in modern society, when there is a conflict between family affection and interests, some people will not hesitate to choose the latter and abandon family affection as if it were a piece of paper.
This story is also a wake-up call for us: when dealing with family property issues, we must not only consider the legal aspects, but also cherish the precious family affection.
In the case of fruitless negotiation, Li resolutely resorted to the matter to law. She not only sued the tenant Wang, but also listed her grandmother, Mrs. Lu, as a third-party co-defendant.
This move undoubtedly pushed the relationship between grandparents and grandchildren to the brink of collapse, and also made this family dispute the focus of social attention.
In court, Li was aggressive, insisting that he had absolute disposal rights as the owner of the property. She claims that even if her grandmother had the right to live in it, she did not have the right to rent and collect rent without permission.
Li's eyes only had a cold calculation of interests, and he couldn't see a trace of family affection. Her attitude sent shudders down the spine of those present.
Faced with her granddaughter's accusations, Mrs. Lu's heart was like a knife. She said in a trembling voice, "I gave you the house in the first place, and I only hoped that you would come to visit me often. But how many times have you actually come to see me? She expressed her helplessness and disappointment, revealing the deep family crisis behind this dispute.
The old man's words were full of bitterness, which made the atmosphere in the courtroom heavy for a while.
When the judge asked Li about visiting his grandmother, Li made up a clumsy lie, saying that he often visited his grandmother on holidays when she was sick. However, this lie was quickly debunked, and the testimonies of neighbors and nursing home staff revealed the truth of the facts.
Li's hypocrisy and indifference were exposed, making her completely lose points on the moral level.
During the trial, the judge carefully reviewed the evidence provided by both parties, including documents such as the property gift agreement and the lease contract. They also listened to Wang's statement as a tenant and a description of Mrs. Lu's living conditions by community workers.
Throughout the trial, the judge always maintained a serious expression and listened carefully to the statements of each party.
After careful consideration, the court made a judgment: it was found that the lease contract between Mrs. Lu and Wang was legal and valid. The court held that "unconditional residence" should include the right to reasonable use and income, and that Mrs. Lu's rental of the house was to meet basic living needs, which fell within the scope of legitimate exercise of rights.
This verdict undoubtedly gave Li a blow to the head. However, instead of reflecting on her actions, she put all the blame for losing the lawsuit on her grandmother. Reluctantly, she appealed, but the High Court dismissed the decision and upheld the original verdict.
This court showdown is not only a contest between legal theory and family affection, but also a confrontation between morality and greed. It profoundly reveals the sad reality of some people in modern society who lose family affection for the sake of profit, and at the same time highlights the protection of vulnerable groups by the law.
This case also sounded the alarm bell for us: when dealing with family conflicts, we must not only abide by the law, but also cherish the hard-won family affection.
The dust has settled on the court verdict, but the family dispute that shocked society has not ended there. Mrs. Lu, who was deeply devastated, made a major decision after a period of painful thinking: she mustered up the courage to apply to the court to take back all the three resettlement houses that had been donated to Li.
In the course of the trial, the court comprehensively considered factors such as Li's failure to perform his maintenance obligations and treachery. After careful evaluation, the court finally upheld Mrs. Lu's claim and ruled to recover the donated property.
This result is undoubtedly a powerful punishment for greedy and selfish behavior, and it also brings hope to other elderly people who may be facing similar situations.
Li not only lost three properties, but also lost the respect of his neighbors and society. Her actions have become a negative teaching material in the mouths of everyone, warning people not to lose precious family affection for petty profits.
This case has sparked a wide range of discussions in society and prompted people to think deeply about filial piety and family ethics. Many people lament that money is important, but the value of family affection cannot be measured by money.
At the same time, this case also highlights the important role of the law in protecting the rights and interests of the elderly, and provides strong support for the construction of a harmonious society.
In the end, justice is at ease in the hearts of the people. Although Mrs. Lu went through a painful process, she also saved her rights and interests under the protection of the law. The enlightenment of this story to us is that in modern society, we must not only cherish family affection, but also learn to use legal weapons to protect our legitimate rights and interests.
Only in this way can we find a balance in complex interpersonal relationships, protect our own rights and interests, and at the same time lose the warmth of human nature.
The purpose of this article is to advocate positive social energy, without vulgarity and other bad guidance. If you are involved in copyright or character infringement, please contact us in time