Please click "Follow" in the upper right corner, so that it is convenient for you to discuss and share, your support is my biggest motivation!
In the early autumn of 2018, in the north of the motherland, Chifeng City, Inner Mongolia, a real estate dispute that had been silent for many years opened again in a solemn courtroom. In the plaintiff's seat, a resolute and calm woman, Wei Sili, is looking straight ahead, while in the defendant's seat, the former owner of the house, Liu Yayun, is now in prison and suffering the baptism of the law.
After a long and tortuous process, this long-standing contradiction finally came to the judgment of the law. With a clutched grip on the long-standing contract and years of hard work to defend her rights to the property, she firmly believes that she is the true owner of the property. However, Liu Yayun has a ghost in his heart, trying to subvert the past transaction agreement, in a vain attempt to carve up the upcoming huge demolition compensation.
The judges scrutinized the evidence submitted by both sides and listened to their respective statements. After in-depth consideration and weighing, the court made a fair judgment in accordance with the relevant legal provisions: it was determined that the house sale contract signed by Liu Yayun and Wei Sili was defective, so the contract was declared invalid. However, this does not mean that Liu Yayun can monopolize the demolition compensation of up to 4.19 million yuan, after accurate calculation, she can only obtain 370,000 yuan, and the remaining 3.82 million yuan belongs to Wei Sili.
Faced with such a verdict, Liu Yayun had mixed feelings in his heart. She knows very well that although justice is difficult to grasp, it will eventually be manifested under the sword of the law. In contrast, although Wei Sili failed to get all the demolition money as she wished, she also fulfilled her wish that year. After all, 15 years ago, she bought this 550-square-meter old house with only 160,000 yuan, and now although she only received 3.82 million yuan in compensation, it has far exceeded the original purchase cost.
Looking back, we go back 15 years. At that time, in an ordinary family in Chifeng City, Inner Mongolia, Liu Yayun was facing severe challenges in life. Her husband, Tian Zhonglin, unfortunately suffered from a serious illness that required long-term medication, and in order to raise high medical expenses, Liu Yayun had to reluctantly cut her love and decided to sell the family's last important asset, an old house with an area of 550 square meters.
In the face of economic embarrassment, Liu Yayun firmly believes that he must quickly find a buyer to solve his urgent needs. As a result, she placed an advertisement for the sale of her home in an influential local newspaper, a move that caught Wei Sili's attention.
Although the price tag of this house reached a high level of 155,000 yuan, it was still considered acceptable for Wei Sili, who was already financially strained, even if the price was slightly more than she could afford. So the two quickly negotiated and agreed on many details, and finally sold the deal at a satisfactory price of 160,000 yuan.
For Liu Yayun, the deal is as timely as a rain after a long drought. With this hard-won money, she was able to pay off all kinds of debts owed to relatives and friends, and then started a new life journey with her two young children.
With firm determination and unremitting efforts, she has gradually grown her own vegetable greenhouse industry, and has successfully cultivated an outstanding son who is studying for a master's degree and an eldest son who is about to enter the palace of marriage. There is no doubt that the sale of this old house has injected new vitality and hope into Liu Yayun's family.
However, compared with Liu Yayun's smoothness, Wei Sili's days after buying this house were not all smooth sailing. At the beginning, the reason why she had a strong interest in Liu Yayun's house was mainly for investment considerations. She hopes that with the help of this property, she can not only have her own warm home, but also obtain a stable income through renting and other means, so as to live a more comfortable life.
However, to Wei Sili's surprise, the house was far more dilapidated than she had imagined. In order to restore it to its original appearance, she had to invest a huge amount of money in a complete renovation, and in the end it cost a whopping 350,000 yuan to give the old house a new lease of life.
However, after a lot of hardships, Wei Sili finally fulfilled her wish on this property, and she settled her family properly and lived a relatively comfortable life on rental income. Just as the two ladies began to enjoy their new lives, fate began to play a joke on them.
One day in 2017, Liu Yayun unexpectedly learned that the local government was planning a large-scale demolition of the area. Hearing this news, Liu Yayun couldn't help but fall into deep thought. She thought that after selling her family property at a low price of 160,000 yuan, it would be enough to alleviate her family's financial difficulties. Now, however, the property has soared dozens of times in just 15 years, and the vast majority of the value-added income has fallen into the hands of Wei Sili.
Under Liu Yayun's repeated persuasion, her youngest son put forward a professional suggestion: Wei Sili actually violated relevant policies and regulations by buying this property back then.
As a resident of an urban hukou, Liu Yayun was unable to buy a rural homestead, and this fact was like a thunderbolt from the blue, which undoubtedly injected a shot of confidence into her! She was convinced that if the sale of these real estate was illegal from beginning to end, then she should receive as much as 4.19 million yuan in compensation for demolition and relocation. With this firm and confident belief, Liu Yayun did not hesitate to visit Wei Simeiya's flower-like residence, and resolutely asked her to share the demolition money.
Faced with this sudden request, Wei Sili, who has always been known for her caution, also had to re-examine the details of the transaction that had been sealed for a long time. When she carefully checked the house sale contract that had been signed by both parties, she suddenly realized: It turned out that this contract had serious legal flaws and could not be established at all! This was undoubtedly a heavy blow to this shrewd and capable Wei Sili.
However, how could Wei Sili, who had already invested a lot of money in this pile of real estate, easily give up her own interests? So, she mercilessly rejected Liu Yayun's request to share. The contradictions between the two sides intensified in an instant, and the situation was about to erupt. In order to defend their respective interests, Liu Yayun and Wei Sili had to stand in court again.
This time, Liu Yayun appeared in the courtroom as a plaintiff, while Wei Sili was forced to sit in the defendant's seat. She took out the purchase contract signed by the two parties that year and the subsequent decoration certificates as a solid backing for her legal ownership. And Liu Yayun also raised strong questions about the illegality of this contract.
The judges listened attentively to the submissions of both sides and conducted an in-depth and detailed review of the relevant evidence. Finally, after careful consideration and judgment, the court made a ruling in accordance with the relevant provisions of national laws: it was determined that the house sale contract signed by Liu Yayun and Wei Sili was seriously flawed, and therefore declared the contract invalid. This undoubtedly made Liu Yayun, who has always been full of confidence, feel unbelievable.
However, the verdict was not entirely tilted in favor of Liu. Taking into account the huge efforts and monetary costs that Wei Sili has put in to maintain the property over the years, the court finally ruled that she should receive 3.82 million yuan of the 4.19 million yuan in demolition compensation, and Liu Yayun could only get 370,000 yuan of it.
Faced with the outcome of this trial, Liu Yayun could not extricate himself from a mixture of disappointment and unwillingness. She knew that she had expected to win a huge compensation of up to 4.19 million yuan in one fell swoop, but it backfired and ended up in such a situation.
However, it should not be overlooked that in the difficult times of the early 20th century, the decision to sell this ancient home out of desperation undoubtedly brought a ray of life to his own life and that of his family.
In contrast, Wei Sili may not have received all the compensation she expected, but she finally fulfilled her long-cherished wish in her early years. Recalling that she only bought this 550-square-meter old house for 160,000 yuan, although she only got 3.82 million yuan, it has far exceeded the cost of her original purchase.
After 15 years of trouble, the property dispute finally came to a successful conclusion in a solemn courtroom. Although neither side fully met expectations, a relatively fair and reasonable solution was finally found.
It is reassuring to note that the incident did not have a more serious social impact, nor did it trigger any violent confrontation.
For Liu Yayun, although she failed to receive the full compensation of 4.19 million yuan as she wished, the compensation of 370,000 yuan was enough to rekindle her hope in life. This amount of money is undoubtedly a relief for her and her family. With this funding, Liu Yayun was finally able to get rid of the difficulties of the past and carefully plan the future development path.
As for Wei Sili, although she also failed to include all the 4.19 million yuan in compensation, the compensation of 3.82 million yuan was already a surprise for her. Recalling that she only bought this old house for 160,000 yuan, and now although she only gets 3.82 million yuan, it is nearly 20 times the original investment. This is undoubtedly a rich reward for a laid-off worker who has experienced economic hardship.
To sum up, this 15-year real estate dispute finally reached a relatively fair and reasonable ending. Although there is still a little regret and unwillingness, at least it has avoided a complete confrontation between the two sides, and it has not caused a wider social impact.
However, this case also reveals some thought-provoking revelations. First of all, this case once again demonstrates the incomparable majesty and shock of the law! Both Liu Yayun and Wei Sili inevitably went to court in the end, and their respective claims were more or less not fully satisfied.
This fact is a strong proof that in real life, we must always abide by the norms of the law, otherwise we will face unforeseen consequences.
Second, this case also gives us insight into how excessive greed often backs on itself. Liu Yayun originally wanted to solve his urgent need by selling the property, but he never expected that the property would soar to dozens of times in just 15 years.
When she witnessed this huge amount of compensation falling into Wei Sili's pocket, a strong jealousy and resentment surged deep in her heart. However, after all, he failed to get his wish, and instead had to bear the legal responsibility of returning 160,000 yuan.
This is undoubtedly a heavy wake-up call to us not to lose ourselves in greed.