Before reading this article, please click "Follow", which is not only convenient for you to discuss and share, but also can bring you a different sense of participation, thank you for your support.
Sentence | No. 8 Explorer
Editor|Explorer No. 8
Jin Yong's novels have always been loved by the audience, and the film and television industry has also continued to remake them.
However, the different casting of "Huang Rong" makes people question whether to pay tribute to the classics or destroy the classics.
So, in different versions, what are the differences between those who play the role of "Huang Rong", and who is the most controversial?
The latest version of "Huang Rong" Zhuang Duffy
Since director Tsui Hark wanted to remake "The Legend of the Condor Heroes", the audience has been looking forward to it, and when the promotional poster was officially released, the effect was immediate.
This version of "The Legend of the Condor Heroes" is played by Zhuang Dafei and Xiao Zhan, and has high expectations in the minds of the audience.
Seeing Xiao Zhan's poster, many young viewers also said that the image looked good, although the dress looked very "modern", in contrast to the previous version, but there were still many people who had great expectations.
Most people were stunned when they saw the heroine, and some netizens said that Zhuang Dafei's version of Huang Rong is the ugliest Huang Rong in history, which is really inconsistent with the character image in the novel.
Zhuang Dafei has played modern dramas before, and played the "mother and daughter" with Yao Chen in the film and television drama "Rock and Roll Crazy Flowers", and his acting skills are also very online, and this is also Zhuang Dafei's first attempt at ancient costumes.
But judging from the poster, Zhuang Dafei does not seem to have met the audience's expectations, and many people have already expressed their dissatisfaction with the casting of this heroine.
Whether Zhuang Dafei can play this role will have to wait for the official release of the film, hoping that she can surprise the audience.
It is precisely because of Zhuang Dafei that the previous version of "Huang Rong" also began to let the audience compare, but the result was unexpected.
The most beautiful 83 edition in history "Huang Rong."
In stark contrast to Zhuang Dafei is the 83 version of Huang Rong played by Weng Meiling, this version of "Shooting the Condor" is regarded as a classic in the minds of many people.
Weng Meiling's Huang Rong has not been surpassed to this day, and it is also the most satisfactory version of the original author.
is not only Weng Meiling, this version is very close to the original book in terms of both the protagonist and the supporting role, and it is well deserved to be called a classic.
Weng Meiling was in her prime at the time, and at the age of 24, she was very beautiful, and the styling and costumes in the play made the audience shine, and she played the eccentric very naturally.
However, such an actor with superb acting skills and outstanding appearance has a thin life, but since Weng Meiling's death, there is rarely a role of Huang Rong who can stand side by side with Weng Meiling.
In addition to the above two, she deserves to be regarded as a classic.
Michelle 76 Edition
Michelle was the first actor to play the role of "Huang Rong", which was all the rage in Hong Kong at the time, and to this day, Michelle's image is unforgettable.
Michelle played Huang Rong's playful, intelligent, and eccentric characteristics to the fullest, and the effect presented was well recognized by the audience.
Because of the difficult filming conditions at that time, and it was not easy to get ahead, Michelle put in a lot of effort behind it in order to successfully shape this role.
She continues to polish her acting skills, and at the same time delves into Huang Rong's character and experience, and privately devotes herself to swordsmanship, reaction and boxing Xi, which is why Michelle will bring the audience the role of Huang Rong who is very in line with the image on the screen.
It is precisely because of her performance in this drama that Michelle was able to emerge and obtain a lot of resources.
In addition, there are also many controversial "Huang Rong", and the following one can be said to be questioned.
The most controversial 03 version of Zhou Xun
Chinese mainland officially remade "The Legend of the Condor Heroes" in 2003, and the remake of director Zhang Jizhong is also a work of domestic entertainment officially going to "rivers and lakes".
However, because of the casting problem, the evaluation can be described as mixed, especially the role of "Huang Rong" played by Zhou Xun, who is known as the "elf of the world", which can be described as controversial.
And the biggest reason why she is controversial is because of her voice and height.
As a mainland actor, Zhou Xun's acting skills are unquestionable, but in this drama, his shortcomings are exposed at a glance.
In the play, Zhou Xun's makeup was not well displayed, and because the director did not choose dubbing, Zhou Xun's original voice was complained that it was a bit of a "male duck" voice, which was really not in line with the role.
But looking at his appearance, Zhou Xun is indeed more in line with the original work, but the destruction is ruined by the makeup and lines.
It is worth mentioning that the original author Jin Yong also praised Zhou Xun's version of Huang Rong, if it weren't for the shortcomings of those shortcomings, I believe Zhou Xun would have been able to stand out in a series of remakes.
The performance of the following person is even more controversial, and the reviews are also mixed.
"Zixia Fairy" 94 version of Zhu Yin
Needless to say, Zhu Yin's performance in "Journey to the West" is praised, and that beautiful smile has made many people unforgettable.
But what many people don't know is that Zhu Yin also played the role of "Huang Rong" when she was in her youth, and it was a big challenge as a newcomer who had just debuted not long ago.
In 1994, Zhu Yin and Zhang Zhilin's cooperation in the remake of "Shooting the Condor" made the audience look forward to it, and Zhu Yin's appearance in the play is naturally undoubted, and she will also play the lively and willful Huang Rong to the fullest.
However, no matter how perfect a person is, he also has shortcomings, Zhu Yin often fiddles with pigtails in the play, and every move is magnified, which often makes the audience feel a little exaggerated and dramatic.
But there are also many people who think that Zhu Yin's performance is very good, and Zhu Yin's version of Huang Rong is still known as the existence of a god in the minds of many people.
In addition, the following Huang Rong, who is known as the most agile version, is also eye-catching, and it is difficult to be surpassed in the minds of many people.
The most agile 08 version of Ariel Lin
At that time, the Xianxia dramas and martial arts dramas filmed by Tang Film and Television were deeply loved by the audience, and "The Legend of Sword and Fairy" was recognized by countless audiences.
In 2006, Tang Ren began filming "Shooting the Condor", starring Ariel Lin and Hu Ge, which is also the first comeback work after Hu Ge's car accident.
At first, many viewers thought that Ariel Lin's image was really not in line with Huang Rong, not only was her body small, but her facial features were not very exquisite.
But Ariel Lin did not give up because of this, but magnified her own advantages and brought the audience a different girl Huang Rong.
After the film was broadcast, Ariel Lin was recognized by many audiences, although there were still some deficiencies in appearance, but she vividly interpreted Huang Rong's girlishness and playfulness.
Therefore, Ariel Lin's performance can be described as very charismatic, and the role played can be regarded as successful.
In addition to the above, the following one is also a version of the classic that was complained about by the audience.
Lin Yanrou 21 version of "Shooting the Condor"
In the 2021 remake of the movie "The Legend of the Condor Heroes: Eighteen Palms of the Dragon", this film is strictly an online drama, in which Lin Yanrou, who plays the role of Huang Rong, can be said to be controversial.
The only impression she brings to the audience in the play is her proud figure, which means that in addition to her figure, there are almost no bright spots in this film.
In addition, there is also a face full of technology, which really makes it difficult for the audience to enter the play, and it is difficult to see the shadow of Huang Rong in the original work.
At the same time, there is also a big problem with age, among all versions of Huang Rong, Lin Yanrou is the oldest, she is 31 years old, and she does not have the eccentric characteristics of Huang Rong at all when shooting.
The film has been controversial since its release, and if you put aside this character, the makeup and styling of the film and the plot have not met the audience's expectations.
I have to say that this version of "Shooting the Condor" is really a classic, and Lin Yanrou, who plays the role of Huang Rong, is a big failure.
epilogue
In "The Legend of the Condor Heroes", which has been flopped so many times, there are many Huang Rong's appearances, which can be said to have their own characteristics and flaws.
So in your mind, which version is called White Moonlight?
(The process and pictures described in the article are all from the Internet, and this article aims to advocate positive social energy and no vulgar and other bad guidance.) If it involves copyright or character infringement issues, please contact us in time, and we will delete the content as soon as possible! ）