preface
After all, some things are not black and white, coupled with sometimes the asymmetry of information, the words spoken out of each other contradict each other, which often causes greater controversy.
For example, the recent incident of a girl bitten by a dog in a community in Sichuan has attracted everyone's attention after spreading on the Internet, first of all, people's condemnation of the dog and the dog's owner, and then some dog lovers can't stand it, resolutely stand up for their dog, then the girl's family raises money online, and then it breaks out that fundraising is tricky, the key is that all parties come out to speak, basically contradict each other, so who is lying?
Let's take a look at the specific situation.
Let's first review the process of the incident
The video of this incident was exposed on the Internet, and we can know from the video:
At that time, a mother and son were suddenly surrounded by two large dogs one black and one white when walking in the community, of which the aggressive performance of the black big dog was particularly strong, and instantly threw the child to the ground, opening his mouth and tearing the child's waist, the mother fought with the big black dog to protect the child, fell to the ground in the process, the big black dog always refused to let go, but increased the intensity of the bite and swayed left and right, but at this time a cleaning aunt found out and came over to use the mop to temporarily frighten the big black dog before letting go and retreating to the side, After a while, the big black dog rushed up again to prepare to bite the child, but was protected by the child's mother and the cleaning aunt to not succeed, and then the child's mother immediately picked up the child and rushed to the hospital.
As can be seen from the video, the child should be injured very seriously, although parents want to protect their children, but still unable to do anything.
Later, some photos of girls injured on the Internet broke out one after another, which were indeed miserable, and they were not sent out here!
The attending doctor who treated the little girl also came out for an interview, telling about the little girl's condition, saying that he had done debridement surgery on the little girl and her vital signs were stable. However, some people said that it is still unknown whether the little girl's kidney can be saved.
So the reason why this little girl is like this, we all turned our eyes and anger on the dog and the owner of the dog.
As a result, the dog ran away after biting the person, but after a lot of searching, the dog was finally caught, and then a few hours later, the dog's owner turned himself in and was finally taken criminal coercive measures.
So who is this dog owner, why did her dog run out to bite, and where was she at that time?
Some of the situation of the dog owner was exposed
After this incident, some media specifically traced the root cause and went to the home of the dog's owner, Tang, to learn about the latest situation.
After visiting and investigating, it was found that the dog who caused the accident was kept in captivity in a courtyard 1.5 kilometers away from the biting community, and there were multiple houses in that yard.
By interviewing some relatives of this Tang, we only went to Tang who not only raised this Rottweiler, but also raised 2 other Labradoodles, and there was a Labrador dog at the scene that day, but this Labrador was his friend Jia.
They keep several dogs together, and they release the dogs every day when it is dark or when there is no one in the yard.
From here we learned that they often put dogs in the yard, which should also be a hidden danger that dogs can run out and hurt people.
That day, it was because the gatekeeper saw that there was no one in the yard and put the dog in the yard, and later a tenant entered the yard and did not lock the door, so he ran out.
I don't know if they often do this, and whether other tenants have any opinions, these are all irregular behaviors of raising dogs, not only do not lead the leash and no one watches, but eventually cause today's serious things.
According to the revelation, this Tang and his father have not been in contact for more than ten years
Previously, the black Rottweiler was tethered to this garage door, and the red circle was where the chain was hanged.
Now that the dog and the owner of the dog have been found, the main problem now is how to hold the girl accountable and the treatment of the girl, we all know that the girl is more seriously injured, so everyone thinks that it may require a lot of money for treatment.
The girl's family initiated fundraising
The first thing that everyone thought of was that the cost of this treatment must be paid by the owner of the dog, but later the media broke the news that the owner of the dog and his family had not paid a penny for the treatment until now.
Later, some people broke the news that the girl's home conditions are not very good, with an annual income of 3-100,000 yuan, and the family has a car, but there is still a debt of 200,000 yuan.
Then if the girl wants to be treated, the cost is a great difficulty, and then the property in the community first paid 100,000 yuan, and then the girl's family launched a fundraising on an online crowdfunding platform.
Looking at this data, more than 80,000 caring people participated in the donation, but most of the donations ranged from 10-50 yuan. But the accumulation of small amounts and the large number of people made up enough for 2 million at once.
It is also this fundraising that has caused many people to question
Everyone questioned the family's fundraising
Many netizens think that if it really reaches the point of cornering, then fundraising, we have nothing to say, now the owner of the dog has found, there will be compensation in the future, their own family also has a house, the property has also been paid in advance, relatives and friends should also be able to help, why do netizens have to pay money as soon as there is a difficulty?
Some people also question what is the basis for this fundraising of 2 million? Compared with the illness of Nanjing's fat brother's daughter, people's operation is convincing, but your operation is incomprehensible. If you raise hundreds of thousands of emergencies first, you can understand that you really need to raise so much money at once?
Then some people questioned whether the fundraising was premeditated and organized, consuming the sympathy of the public.
In addition to questioning the family's fundraising behavior, some people also began to spread on the Internet that there was a reason for this incident, not to blame the dog, but the little girl herself stoned the dog first.
Of course, such claims have been officially debunked.
In addition to these rumors, the emergence of some behaviors also made everyone angry at this family, because some people claiming to be the child's uncle broadcast live on the Internet to bring goods, using this topic to hype.
However, later some people began to come out to refute rumors, saying that this uncle was fake, so whether this person is an uncle or not, there is no accurate information until now.
The parties responded with contradictions and punched each other in the face
The first is the lawyer's response
After some rumors came out on the Internet, many people who had previously donated felt that they had been deceived, so they asked for refunds, and their lawyers couldn't sit still and issued a statement solemnly accusing some netizens of their behavior.
This is followed by a statement from the fundraising platform
When there was a lot of noise on the Internet, the fundraising platform couldn't sit still and came out in time to speak out.
1. If the fundraising exceeds 500,000 yuan on the platform, a certificate of the hospital must be issued;
2. This fundraising of 2 million yuan is the amount estimated by the girl's family itself;
So does the hospital issue a certificate? Later, the hospital also responded.
The hospital came forward to respond to the controversy
After the platform said that fundraising must have a certificate from the hospital, everyone thought that the hospital issued this certificate to the child, so there was evidence for using so much money. But the hospital responded by not doing so:
1. The hospital has not issued any certificates so far:
2. As of October 20, the child's account had paid 110,000 yuan in advance, resulting in 30,000 yuan of medical expenses.
3. Later, on the morning of October 23, the media announced the latest situation, the little girl had been transferred out of the ICU, and the total medical expenses spent from the 16th to the 23rd were only nearly 60,000 yuan, and the amount of advance payment in her medical account was 220,000 yuan.
After reading these revelations, we know:
1. Many people were originally condemning the hospital treatment fee is too expensive, now we know that it was not as expensive as imagined, and only 60,000 yuan has been spent now, the balance in the account is sufficient, and there is no need to donate money;
2. The fundraising behavior of this family and platform is obviously a violation of the process, not a compliance behavior.
One doctor couldn't stand it anymore and came out to speak:
1. I heard about the girl's condition through my classmates in West China Hospital, and it is not considered a serious illness in the intensive care unit;
2. Because of the young age, the wound was selected for sedation according to the treatment of the exposed wound, and other equipment was useless, that is, the conservative treatment taken, the cost of which was not very much.
So in his opinion, as soon as he opened his mouth to raise 2 million, he felt that he had changed his taste.
Later, some netizens broke the news that they are locals, and they are only 500 meters away from the place of the incident, and the dog owner's family is not short of money, and there should be compensation in the future.
The local civil affairs bureau also said that it would pay for the treatment in advance, so there must be no shortage of money for treatment, and there will be compensation in the future, so it is indeed chilling to start fundraising in such a hurry.
Some people also said that fundraising should be urgent, and this family's fundraising is a spare, and without needing so much money, they actually began to talk to netizen lions.
Some people also say that this family must be seduced by this lawyer, you can check the black history of this lawyer, where there is heat or money to earn, drill specifically.
Conclusion
For this matter, there are too many rumors on the Internet, I don't know which one is right, looking at the voices of support and opposition, it seems to make some sense, but at least from this matter, we can see that we still have a lot of caring people, but we don't want some kindness to be used, after all, there are many people who owe debts, rent, work hard to earn money to support themselves, and hope that those who raise funds will not chill the hearts of these people, then there will be fewer and fewer caring people in the future, When there is another emergency, these people's path is cut off.
Netizens, what do you think?