In June 2020, Zhang Ming, who was resting at his home in Nantong, Jiangsu Province, received a phone call from a stranger claiming that his father had fainted in a supermarket and had been taken to the hospital for rescue! After receiving the call, he immediately went to the hospital with his mother, and the old man had already died of a sudden heart attack.
Nantong, Jiangsu
What made Zhang Ming wonder was that his father was usually in good health, and he would check it regularly, but just by buying a vegetable downstairs, how could he suddenly have a heart attack? Then he learned that the old man stole two eggs and was dragged and torn by the supermarket staff, and what was even more infuriating was that he had obviously put down the eggs, and these people still did not forgive, which eventually led to the old man having a heart attack!
After Zhang Ming and the supermarket negotiated fruitlessly, he immediately sued the supermarket in court, demanding compensation of about 380,000 yuan! But the person in charge of the supermarket said: "Not a single point will be lost!" "Why is the head of the supermarket so tough? Isn't the truth what Zhang Ming saw? So what is the truth behind this? How will the court impose penalties?
first aid
A bad day
Uncle Zhang suddenly fainted at the exit of the supermarket and was sent to the emergency center in less than twenty minutes, but in the end he was unable to return to the sky. This was a sudden blow to his son Zhang Ming, and it was also a sleepless night for the supermarket staff who clashed with the uncle at that time. Tian Miao, the person in charge of the supermarket, learned about the situation for the first time and thought that the staff did not have any problems, so there was no need to worry too much.
Incident monitoring
However, after Zhang Ming lost his father, he learned that his father had a conflict with the supermarket at that time, so he came to ask for an explanation in anger. According to the supermarket, everything was because Uncle Zhang stole two eggs, so they clashed with Uncle Zhang. But no one knows why Uncle Zhang was so excited that he fainted at the entrance of the supermarket.
Zhang Ming did not believe the side of the supermarket at all, he checked the surveillance at the time of the incident, it is true that his father stole the egg first, but then returned to the supermarket to put the egg down. But even after putting down the eggs, the supermarket staff still dragged him with their hands deadly, and there were so many onlookers, it was precisely because the staff mishandled them, which caused the old man to be emotionally excited, which caused a heart attack.
Zhang ming
Zhang Ming demanded that the supermarket must pay compensation, otherwise it would be sued in court! Tian Miao, the person in charge of the supermarket, believes that the old man did faint at the entrance of the supermarket, and for humanitarian reasons, they can pay 20,000 yuan for comfort, but it is by no means a compensation! The twenty thousand yuan was far below Zhang Ming's expectations, how could he agree? Since the consultation had collapsed, Zhang Ming coldly left a harsh sentence: "Then see you in court!" ”
Egg
Restore the truth of the matter
So why are supermarkets so tough? Is the truth of the matter not at all what Zhang Ming saw? Let's take a look at the situation at that time! On the day of the incident, the staff responsible for handling this matter was Luo Hongxia, who had been engaged in this business for many years and was also very responsible for the work.
It was a Saturday, and the supermarket was crowded and unusually busy. It was at this time that Uncle Zhang came to the supermarket to buy eggs, and after carefully selecting a basket of eggs for a long time, he finally filled the plastic bag. Subsequently, he weighed the settlement, and Luo Hongxia sealed the bag for him.
monitor
But Uncle Zhang lifted the bag and just took a few steps and then turned back to the side of the egg basket, and when no one paid attention to him, he took two eggs and hid them directly in his trouser pocket!
Uncle Zhang immediately left to prepare for the checkout, but what he didn't know was that Luo Hongxia happened to see this scene. Although it is only a quick glance, I am not even sure whether the old man puts an egg in his pants pocket or his own things, but in recent years, some old people always like to take advantage of some small advantages, and this atmosphere is getting stronger and stronger. Ordinary people see that the other party is an old man, and it is only two eggs, so they turn a blind eye, what if the old man plays a rogue to blackmail himself?
Luo Hongxia
But the responsible Luo Hongxia believes that even if it is two eggs, it is a small thing for the supermarket, and it has little to do with her own salary, but as a member of the supermarket, naturally this kind of thing is not allowed to happen, after all, for a job, it is natural to take responsibility! But the experienced her did not shout, after all, at this time, she was not sure whether the uncle really stole two eggs!
Luo Hongxia followed Behind Uncle Zhang, and it turned out that Uncle Zhang casually turned around the supermarket and then went to the cash register! So she immediately informed the store manager Zhou Yulan, and the two immediately came to the cash register to check. After Uncle Zhang finished checking out, he planned to leave, and Zhou Yulan had to walk quickly to Uncle Zhang's side and tentatively asked, "Uncle, did you forget something about checkout?" ”
The head of the supermarket
Unexpectedly, Uncle Zhang seemed to want to use anger to hide his inner uneasiness, and he asked rhetorically: "Didn't you just settle the bill?" Also called me to check out! Luo Hongxia heard that Uncle Da didn't admit it at all, so she reminded her again: "Uncle, is there something in your pants pocket that you forgot to check out?" After hearing this, Uncle Zhang seemed to have been punctured by the secret, and the tension and shame all poured out for a while, and he could not speak with his clothes tightly.
At this time, there are already a lot of people around the crowd watching the liveliness, to uncle Zhang face to admit that stealing things is simply impossible to do, in order to give uncle a step, Zhou Yulan told him: "Uncle, let's settle the bill, or you put it back!" The people around him actually knew what was happening and urged him to put things back!
monitor
The flushed Uncle Zhang began to defend himself continuously, and rushed straight to the supermarket, even knocked over a lot of things on the way, looking at the uncontrollable emotions of Uncle Zhang, Zhou Yulan could only pull one of his corners, the two dragged and dragged into the supermarket, and in less than a moment the two pulled and pulled and walked out of the supermarket.
During the period, Uncle Zhang did not tell Zhou Yulan and Luo Hongxia that the eggs had been put in the supermarket in the push, and Zhou Yulan did not notice at all, so she still pulled Uncle Zhang to prevent escape. At this time, there were more and more melon-eating people around, and Uncle Zhang had just walked out of the supermarket and suddenly fainted on the ground in full view of everyone. Zhou Yulan was also startled by Uncle Zhang's sudden move!
Crowd of onlookers
There were more and more crowds of onlookers, and some people pointed out that maybe the old man wanted to blackmail people! There have been such reports before! But Zhou Yulan still checked the situation of the old man and thought that there might be an accident! At this time, several people stood up and dealt with the fainting old man urgently! Then Zhou Yulan called the emergency number! Ten minutes later, Uncle Zhang was sent to the hospital, and no one admitted that the old man died unexpectedly!
Court-to-court confrontation
Zhou Yulan immediately reported the matter to the person in charge, Tian Miao, after understanding the causes and consequences, Tian Miao believed that their disposal was very appropriate, and there was no illegal operation. Uncle Zhang's son Zhang Ming thought that it was originally a matter of two eggs, but it was operated by the supermarket and became a life thing, and naturally should pay full responsibility!
Moreover, Zhang Ming even proposed in court that his father's pension of about five thousand a month was enough to eat and drink in life, so how could he take advantage of it and steal eggs? So this is not at all reasonable, the real reason is that the eggs that the father bought in the supermarket several times before are bad, they are sure that the supermarket is buying fake and shoddy products, it may be that the old father is angry, but wants to retaliate against the unscrupulous business of the supermarket! That's why I started to do it!
pension
In the face of Zhang Ming's statement, everyone felt ridiculous. Because this is obviously a lame reason for whitewashing, stealing is stealing, how can the reason for stealing be so grandiose?
For Zhang Ming's statement, Zhou Yulan pointed out that the eggs in the supermarket are available for customers to choose, they or believe that every store will not force customers to sell good eggs, in addition, eggs from the shell, it is difficult to see whether the inside is good! Who can guarantee that all the eggs picked by Uncle Zhang are good?
law
Zhang Ming could only be dumbfounded by this explanation, and then he raised a suspicious point. That is, the surveillance shows that the old man returned to the supermarket and put the eggs down, and as a result, the supermarket employees still pulled and pulled on him, not sparing. This leads to the old man's emotional agitation, which leads to a heart attack!
For Zhang Ming's statement, Luo Hongxia said that there were many people watching at that time, and they didn't know that the old man put the egg back, not to mention that the old man didn't explain the situation to them at all, so they were completely unaware of the whole process! All in all, in the face of the various reasons found by Zhang Ming, the supermarket employees have explained, and it seems that each explanation is very reasonable.
trial
In the end, the court also ushered in the first-instance judgment, rejecting Zhang Ming's litigation claim and determining that the supermarket was not liable. The reason they gave was that Uncle Zhang himself had such an illness and had never explained the situation to the supermarket staff. They dealt with it urgently and reasonably without their knowledge. Afterwards, the old man was also sent to the hospital in time.
Zhang Ming naturally did not understand the outcome of this trial and immediately filed an appeal request. After the court's second-instance trial, the first-instance trial result was found to be valid and Zhang Ming's litigation claim was rejected. After the results of the second trial came down, the supermarket staff were also relieved, after all, no one wanted to put on such a thing!
court
This case also caused a heated discussion among the majority of netizens at the time, and after seeing the verdict, they clapped their hands and applauded. They believe that this result is a wake-up call for those who love to take advantage, and that people need to think twice about doing things, and they can't do illegal and immoral things, otherwise they may end up with more than they lose.