Friends often send me numismatic pictures for me to see, but online, I usually remain silent.
It's really not an X, if I give you numismatic finger-pointing, the nature will change.
I want to say the real thing, some open door fake to say that it is a bad conscience, and there are some rare varieties that I have never seen myself, and casually evaluating it is the wrong person.2 I'm going to say fake, you might think I have a ghost in my heart and want to fool your coins.
Expert Treasure (picture and text independent)
I am not an expert, let alone an academic scholar, but a collector. Moreover, even if they are real experts and scholars, they are also human beings, and they will make mistakes, and it is impossible for one person to learn the vast collection knowledge.
What's more, in today's collection industry, "experts walk everywhere, masters are like dogs", how many people bend down in front of money?
When discussing coins with friends, I just ask, "Do you like it yourself?" ”
like! Well, you just have to play with coins, and the rest is left to the most bullish expert in the collecting world: time!
Song Ben ordered the star officer to spend money
In fact, most people play collecting from the "National Treasure Gang" stage, at first they will feel that everything looks like "baby", thinking that it is very valuable. However, after being "beaten" by reality many times, there will be a feeling of wind and noise, and some people will go from one extreme to the other, looking like a fake.
I remember that after just touching coins for a while, I found a Song Dynasty Honmei Star Official's money in an antique shop, which was much different from the one in the picture above, and the bag pulp that had been played with was too "cooked". At that time, I sent it to the Internet to ask quan friends to evaluate, and at that time, I thought that those who played coins were "big gods".
As a result, what awaits is all kinds of cynicism, what fakes, low imitations, fellow countrymen, extreme irony. Everyone just looked at the picture and said it conclusively, saying that I myself suspected that it was fake, listening to the crisp sound and feeling that it was not like calcified old copper, but seeing the rust color of the bone and feeling that the counterfeit could not be made, very tangled.
It wasn't until more than two years ago that I sold the coin to a veteran quanyou, who then successfully auctioned it in the garden. At that time, some people still said fakes, and pulled a bunch of "conspiracy theories", at that time I already had a number in my mind: the original numismatic world is not all "big gods", there are more "keyboard men" who do not know how to pretend to understand and are self-righteous.
Two ancestral silver dollars shared by bartenders
I also saw the same story in Tieba . In 2019, a college student Quanyou issued two silver dollars in Tieba, one HongXian Feilong and one Xu Shichang Renshou Tongdeng, he introduced that these two coins were obtained by his grandfather when he was an apprentice in Tianjin Qianzhuang more than 80 years ago.
At that time, there was a heated discussion in Tieba and the common reaction was: "What? This big warlord coin is also what you can have? It is also a national treasure gang that makes up stories with so-called ancestral treasures. ”
The question is, how many people have actually seen this rare coin? Most people just look at online pictures. It is simple to type a keyboard on the Internet, it is easy to say a fake, but it is irresponsible to pick faults and throw stones, which is just a mouthful.
Later, college student Quanyou had no choice but to delete the post.
Picture source Tieba spring friends to share
Just when everyone has forgotten about this matter, a quanyou was hanging out in the seafood market one day, but was surprised to find that someone was "showing off" these two silver dollars, exactly the same state, successfully entered the P box, and got a high score of MS62! It's just that the holder has become "so-and-so Spring Village".
With a little thought, you can guess that the college student Quanyou was hit, and then sold the two truly inherited treasures to the Izumi merchant at a very low price. And as soon as the businessman gets his hand, he quickly goes to the rating and earns two suites for free!
I don't know the specific process, but in the collecting world, deliberately suppressing other people's collections and then taking the opportunity to receive goods at a low price is an old routine. So if the college student doesn't listen to others and slowly explores the truth and falsehood on his own, it may not be the result.
Jin Dynasty Zhen yu Tongbao Fold two
There are many national treasure gangs in the collecting world, which is undeniable, and they have even become the mainstream group of "high goods", which has disrupted the muddy waters and made the reputation of minzang extremely poor. However, some "brick family beasts" say that the folk have no treasures at all, which is even more sinister, so that countless treasures are stained with dust and dirt, and there is no way to find a way.
Most of the Tibetan friends on the Internet can say the tao when facing general goods, but when they encounter high goods that are not fake, they will often evaluate arbitrarily and be occupied by the psychology of sour grapes. Everyone can be an expert, but only a few people make a name for themselves by their knowledge and courage.
The only person in this world who is really good to you is your family. There is only time in this world to identify the true and false, to be completely fair and just experts.