Continued from the previous article -
Looking at this history from today's perspective, it is not so appropriate to say that the second master was carelessly losing Jingzhou. Regardless of the perennial discussion on the Internet, Jingzhou and Yizhou cannot quickly support each other due to geographical factors. The real reason for the defeat of Jingzhou, the contemptible people think that the oldest theory is the most reliable, Guan Yu's defeat is due to his own personality - rigid self-use!
Lu Fang was an old man who followed Liu Bei early, if it were not for the early death of Lady Mi, Mi Fang would be the uncle of the country! He followed the emperor to start from Xuzhou, all the way through Yecheng, Runan, Xinye, Changsakapo, Jiangxia and other places, although his intelligence is mediocre, but in terms of loyalty, Liu Bei absolutely believes in Lu Fang, an old man who came from a small age, otherwise he would not have entrusted such an important strategic place as Nan County to him to guard.
However, such an "old revolutionary" who had followed Liu Bei for many years turned against Eastern Wu at the juncture when the great cause of Shu Han was booming, which was considered to have indirectly killed Guan Yu! This abnormal behavior seems extremely unreasonable! With Elfang's seniority and foundation, the reason why there is such a move is not difficult to guess, that is, it is not at odds with Guan Yu!
Guan Erye's loyalty and righteousness are unmatched, this is well known, but no one is perfect, compared to his world-known advantages, Guan Erye's shortcomings are also very obvious, that is, arrogance and arrogance, and other idle people do not pay attention to them.
The second master regards himself as a hero, and cherishes the hero and values the hero, and uses this code of conduct. As long as it is a hero identified by himself, even if it is an opponent, Guan Yu is also extremely admired, such as Yu Ban and Pound De when the "Flooded Seventh Army"; but if they are mediocre, or if they can't see it, even if they are teammates, it is difficult to get Guan Yu's approval, it is obvious that Elfang is this kind of person!
When Guan Yu was in charge of Jingzhou, Fu Shiren, the general of the Southern Commandery Taishou and the public security guard, was despised by Guan Yu because of the disadvantage of raising grain and grass, so after Guan Yu's expedition, he surrendered to Wu, and Guan Yu was thus crossed the river by Lü Meng and defeated Maicheng!
If you look at it this way, Lu Fang and Fu Shiren are also too small people, and they easily surrender to the enemy just after being reprimanded by shangguan, but is this really the case? But the history books only record so much, and the rest of the things can only be speculated by Guan Yu's personality.
The following is a contemptible speculation: Yi Lufang and Fu Shiren must have already had a reaction, otherwise they would not have surrendered to Eastern Wu because of a letter from Lü Meng, which is enough to show that the two were certainly slighted more than once under Guan Yu's hands.
Both of them were old men who followed Liu Bei (Fu Shiren began to follow Liu Bei in Youzhou, earlier than the brothers Lu Zhu and Lu Fang), and it can be boldly guessed that they were under Guan Yu, but they did not get the treatment that the Elders of Shu Han deserved, or did not get the treatment they wanted, and they were always called and drunk by Guan Yu from above, and they had to endure all kinds of ridicule from time to time, I am afraid that this is the real reason for the surrender of the two of them!
In fact, when Guan Yu learned that the backyard was on fire and Nan County was lost, he still had a chance to overturn, and no matter how bad it was, he could save his life and withdraw from Jingzhou, and contact Liu Bei to try to fight again. It is a pity that the town guards the mediocre - Liu Feng, Liu Bei's adopted son, and the capricious villain Meng Da! The two ignored Guan Yu's pleas for help, causing Guan Yu to be isolated and defeated and captured under the attack of Wei and Wu. This was another indirect cause of Guan Yu's downfall.
Guan Yu's careless loss of Jingzhou has many factors, but the main reason is his own personality
The situation of Liu Feng and Meng Da at this time was similar to that of Ma Chao, who formed a family of their own, holding the military and political power of Shangyong County, and wandering outside the Shu Han regime, equivalent to an independent warlord. Therefore, the survival of Guan Yu and Jingzhou did not matter much to these two people, they only considered their own interests - after Guan Yu flooded the Seventh Army, the power of the Jingxiang generation increased greatly, and it was not bad to be killed by Wu wei and Wei! outcome......
Meng Da is a villain, there is nothing to say, but Liu Feng is Liu Bei's adopted son, once Liu Bei's heir, and he can actually see death and not save, can only say that this person is too ignorant of advance and retreat!
Because Liu Chan had already been made crown prince, Liu Feng's existence was already embarrassing enough, but Liu Bei regarded himself as benevolent and did not find the opportunity to start. As a result, Liu Feng dug his own grave and felt that he had a father-son relationship with Liu Bei, and even Guan Yu, the second-largest figure of the Shu Han Dynasty, did not pay attention to it, and such a strategic place as Jingzhou could be abandoned. Afterwards, he also refused Meng Da's move to surrender Wei, returned to Chengdu alone, and was killed by Liu Bei, which was really stupid!
As for Meng Da, this person is a complete warlord, who only cares about his own interests, has no overall view of the situation, and does not recognize the situation. At that time, the three points of the world were the trend of the times, and he also wanted to jump back and forth between Wei and Shu left and right, thinking of the idea of dividing one side, Meng Da's act was basically the grasshopper shaking the tree to find his own way to die (Meng Da first descended on Shu, then on Wei, and then on Shu, and finally was killed by Sima Yi)!
The reason why Liu Meng and the two people have such behavior is that they are blind, and their thinking concepts are still stuck in the era of the division of the masses at the end of the Eastern Han Dynasty. The three major powers have completely gained a foothold, so why not allow small local forces to exist? Liu Feng thought that he did not know how to advance or retreat, Meng Da danced on the tip of the sword for many years, and these two people handled everything they did with warlord thinking and villain behavior, and it was not a pity to die! General Guan's death at the hands of these gangs is truly sad and regrettable...
But if you think about it carefully, the two of them are anti-water, and Liu Meng and Liu Meng are not saved when they see death, and this phenomenon does not show how much Guan Yu is a person who cannot be a person and how badly he gets along with his colleagues! This kind of person, according to modern words, is too low emotional intelligence! Guan Yu's death was caused by his personality, and he really hated others! As a human subject, Guan Yu is undoubtedly a failure, but as a brother, Yun Chang is undoubtedly the best candidate!
Shangyong is the only passage connecting Hanzhong, and Nan County is located in Jingzhou, and such an important two strategic governors actually did not bird Guan Yu at the same time at a critical moment
Back to the beginning, a lot of marketing numbers on the Internet said: The loss of Jingzhou is caused by the innate inadequacy of the Shu Han - because jingzhou and Yizhou are separated by mountains and rivers, and they cannot rescue each other. Therefore, the marketing numbers threw the pot directly to Zhuge Liang! It is said that its strategic planning in Longzhong has a birth defect! At first glance, this statement seems to make a lot of sense, and then look at the map, yes, isn't that it! The topography difference between Jingyi and Jingyi is so great, it is true that Zhuge Liang's initial plan for Liu Bei is problematic!
But what about the facts? The general trend of the world has long been seen through by Kong Ming, Cao Cao in the north has no one to shake, Eastern Wu Sun has been running for three generations, the territory of these two major forces has been stabilized, only Liu Biao in Jingzhou and Liu Zhang in Yizhou are dimwitted, do not take these two places, is it necessary for Liu Bei to abandon the Central Plains and go to Fight Liangzhou with Ma Chao? Therefore, the words and views of these network marketing numbers should not be credulous, and the truth or falsity of the facts still needs to be considered by themselves!
Guan Yu's life is a tragedy, and the life of another big bull of Shu Han is not much more than let go, probably because of the same country, like its protagonist, born with tragic and magnificent colors! Once Jingzhou was lost, the general trend of the world was determined, manpower could not win the sky after all, Liu Bei could not, and his successor, even if his name stood for thousands of years, could not reverse the situation.
10 Marquis Zhuge Liang of Wu
Seeing this title, I think all the princes will show a trance, and secretly say: Finally speaking of him! Yes, whether it is praised or denied, most people cannot deny that Zhuge Liang is the most famous person in the Three Kingdoms (probably the most controversial person)! It is thought that Kong Ming's literary style and ability to govern are not controversial, but when it comes to Kong Ming's military ability, ten thousand people may have 100,000 theories.
In view of the fact that there is too much discussion about Kong Ming on the Internet, and all the battle examples from birth to death have been brought out and discussed to the end, the contempt will not be pushed more. Today is another way, from another perspective to talk about Kong Ming, by the way, for the princes to show how awesome Kong Ming's fan group is!
to be continued......