laitimes

After "Can you manage it", "The Voice of God" did not have Wang Linkai, and the smell of gunpowder finally faded

On the night of May 26, Zhejiang Satellite TV broadcast the latest program of "The Voice of God". In this issue, singers such as Wang Linkai and Yu Wenwen left in exchange for singers such as Zheng Xiuyan and Xue Kaiqi. In this issue, the comments of music critics and teachers are also significantly milder. Teacher Liang Yuan even recognized Zheng Xiuyan's singing. (This article is accompanied by a picture using the free circulation poster content published in the 5th issue of "The Voice of God".) )

After "Can you manage it", "The Voice of God" did not have Wang Linkai, and the smell of gunpowder finally faded

Earlier, on the stage of "The Voice of God", music critic Liang Yuan commented on Wang Linkai's singing, which encountered many counterattacks from him. Wang Linkai's fans believe that this is the straightforward character of the little ghost, and when they encounter something unpleasant, they will fight back. And ordinary fans think that what kind of character this is, this is typical restlessness and lack of quality, our music scene to make this kind of traffic singer famous, is an insult to our music scene.

On the stage of the fourth issue of "The Voice of God", in the face of Mr. Liang Yuan's comments, Wang Linkai released a lot of dissatisfied remarks that made netizens dissatisfied, including but not limited to "I didn't bring my headphones properly, you say it again", "Can you manage it" and other words. After this episode was broadcast, it also caused a lot of online controversy. Not only Wang Linkai has to face the doubts about the quality direction of ordinary fans, but the program team of Zhejiang Satellite TV's "Voice of God" also faces the question of whether this is a script arrangement.

After "Can you manage it", "The Voice of God" did not have Wang Linkai, and the smell of gunpowder finally faded

In the fifth episode of "The Voice of God" broadcast on the evening of May 26, singers such as Wang Linkai and Yu Wenwen did not appear on the stage, in contrast, singers such as Zheng Xiuyan and Xue Kaiqi appeared on the stage. In terms of the program group, it did not give the explanation of why these singers left earlier. It is estimated that several singers signed the first 4 issues. The format of the "Voice of God" program is definitely a little embarrassing.

After Wang Linkai left, the interaction between the singer and the music critic teacher on the stage of "The Voice of God" was obviously much milder, and there was no earlier smell of gunpowder. In the fifth issue of the work, the teachers of the music jury sang to the singers, which obviously opened the Kwakwa group mode. The reasons for this pattern are, I guess, are no more than two possibilities. First, the singers sing really well, with zero flaws, and there is no fault. Second, the teachers of the music jury have learned to be smart, why tell the truth to criticize anyone, everyone coaxed each other, making the audience happy.

After "Can you manage it", "The Voice of God" did not have Wang Linkai, and the smell of gunpowder finally faded

This gentleness actually exposes the irrationality of the program arrangement of "The Voice of God". Especially in the music jury link, it is more debatable. Invite singers who have become popular to sing, do you need a review group? This is something that needs to be looked at dialectically.

From the audience's point of view, in fact, it is necessary to review the panel, especially the real professors in the field of music to come out and comment, tell the audience what is good music and what is not. However, the teachers of the review panel invited on the stage of "The Voice of God" also seem to lack a little convincing in terms of academic qualifications and occupations. Especially in this issue, the teacher of the review group wrote songs for singer Zhang Liangying. This is obviously a boast within the house.

After "Can you manage it", "The Voice of God" did not have Wang Linkai, and the smell of gunpowder finally faded

Musical works certainly can't be flawless. And when singing live, there must be something that can be improved. If "The Voice of God" invites professors and teachers in the real music field to comment, the effect should have music science value. Among the members of the review group today, except for Mr. Liang Yuan, who dared to say a few words of truth, the other members were all slippery tongues - they understood that they were here to make money, and there was no need to offend anyone.

This is consistent with the "film critic bastard" attribute in the "circle" of film critics. Among film critics, many workers who really understand film and literary and art theory automatically keep their distance from the film side, try not to make friends with screenwriters and directors, let alone make friends with film and television star artists. These comments, of course, make many criticized playmakers anxious, and sometimes, they also make the praised playwrights eager to say thank you in person.

After "Can you manage it", "The Voice of God" did not have Wang Linkai, and the smell of gunpowder finally faded

There are film critics who stick to their hearts, and there are film critics. This batch of bastards, the movies that are screened, the scene must come, the scene is applauded, and when the movie is watched, it can only be seen that it is good, and there is not the slightest problem. This is actually a big flicker, fooling fans into buying tickets. And this batch of bastards often become an important side dish in film marketing, used to prove that "our movies are really good, and film critics applaud them when they see them" - in other words, film critics praise the mixture, which is itself a shame for a movie.

In the music critic circle, there is also such a problem. Music critics are bastards, and they also like to applaud the scene. If the music field always engages in this kind of side dishes, it will seem very low-grade. In the 5 issues of the fourth season of "The Voice of God", in fact, only Liang Yuan has criticized and suggested the songs sung on stage. Is this another kind of embarrassment?

After "Can you manage it", "The Voice of God" did not have Wang Linkai, and the smell of gunpowder finally faded

In addition to the show, Liang Yuan asked the group of traffic fans who sent private messages to harass him on his social media platform: I quit the circle, I don't work as a music critic, I can support myself, you ask, Wang Linkai dare to withdraw from the circle? This kind of questioning, in fact, says the key point, music critics can only uphold their hearts, adhere to artistic ethics, and comment on the music works themselves when they do not have much interest in the music industry.

Therefore, I feel that the professors who teach at the conservatory have their own stable salaries, and they don't have to look at the faces of the singers to speak some truth. On the stage of "The Voice of God", the review group should invite teachers who dare to tell the truth, otherwise, it is better to cancel this link. (Text/Ma Qingyun)

Read on