In April, Xie Na and Zhang Jie both appeared at the high-speed rail station, when many people pointed their mobile phones at the couple.
At this time, Xie Na's assistant suddenly rushed up and knocked out the photographer's mobile phone. After the video was posted online, it caused an uproar.
Later, Xie Na's studio apologized, saying that there were many professional follow-up filming at that time, and their shooting interfered with public order, and also caused Xie Na and his wife to delay the high-speed train. Therefore, Xie Na's assistant will be impulsive and turn off the photographer's mobile phone.
But judging by the video, it doesn't seem to be what Xena's studio says.
First of all, Xie Na and Zhang Jie were surrounded by few people at all, and they did not reach the level of "congestion" and "interference with public order" at all.
Secondly, the photographer is also several steps away from them, which will not affect their walking. Xie Na's assistant also walked several steps before rushing over and knocking off the photographer's mobile phone.
The turmoil was caused by Xie Na's assistant, but the negative impact was all attributed to Xie Na herself. Some netizens also believe that this is Xie Na's self-directed and self-acting, and she deliberately bought a hot search, because "Riding the Wind 2023" was about to be broadcast at that time.
From a rational point of view, the possibility of Xie Na directing and acting is zero, after all, "calling mobile phones" is not a good thing, and it is harmful to her and not beneficial.
Speaking of "Riding the Wind 2023", after the program was broadcast, Xie Na, as the "first sister of Mango TV", naturally received extremely high attention.
In the performance of the first stage, Xie Na's singing and dancing performance was very sincere. Why do you say that? Because of the 33 sisters who participated in the show, more than half of them were "standing on the pile" to sing, and there was no dance display at all.
As a host, Xie Na spends time and energy preparing for the singing and dancing stage, which shows that she is really treating it with heart.
But Xie Na's efforts did not win unanimous recognition from the audience. In the first performance of the show, Xie Na, as the captain, led the 5 older sisters to perform the singing and dancing stage "Dragon Fist".
The sisters played drums, sang, and danced, and they did everything they could, and they wanted to come out on top in the show.
According to the voting results of the audience, Xie Na's "Dragon Fist" was indeed wonderful and won the competition.
But the audience in front of the screen didn't think so, everyone thought that the stage of "Dragon Fist" was very greasy, and the expressions of the sisters were too strong, especially Xie Na.
Although Xie Na is practicing hard, the effect of dancing is very similar to the dance posture of Huang Lei's wife Sun Li, the movement is standard, but there is no beauty. Xie Na is not very good at singing, purely by shouting.
When the audience found that the score of "Dragon Fist" was higher than that of "Sea of Flowers", everyone expressed their incomprehension and complained: Xie Na is worthy of being Mango's own daughter, and the intention to hold Xie Na is too obvious.
On a certain petal's rating page, almost half of the content in the popular comments is to spit on Xie Na, saying that she is a "relationship household" and saying that "Jay Chou has to lose to Xie Na when he comes".
After that, a large number of live audiences voiced and said: There is no shady scene, the effect of "Dragon Fist" is very good and very burning, and the high number of votes is deserved.
Think about it, the third episode of the show, did Xie Na do something wrong? She tried hard to liven up the atmosphere and train her singing and dancing, but there were still a large number of audiences who did not like her.
Digging deeper, Xie Na's mixed reputation for the audience began when she stepped onto the stage of "Happy Camp".
First, Xie Na is "crazy" funny
Xie Na's relationship with "Fast Ben" began in 1999, and in 2002, Xie Na appeared in the "Fast Ben" program as an location host.
In 2004, because Li Xiang left "Fast Ben", the program group creatively proposed the model of "host group" and also held the "host elimination competition."
Originally, Xie Na was eliminated in July 2005, but returned in October, and since then she has been on the stage of "Fast Ben" for a long time as a member of the happy family.
There is such a question: Why do so many people not like Xie Na?
The first popular answer was: When I was a child, my father didn't let me watch Happy Base Camp, saying that Xie Na was crazy, and when I grew up, I found out that my father was right.
Xie Na's "crazy" funny route has always been very controversial.
Audiences who like Xie Na will be amused by her, and she has created many classic characters on the stage of "Fast Ben", such as "Hot Pot Beauty", "Sun Goddess", "Malanshan Sister" and so on.
Xie Na is particularly open-minded, can be ridiculed, caricatured, played ugly, and has no idol baggage. And her ability to imitate is really strong.
It is because she does not care too much about the image, because the audience will think that Xie Na is too crazy. In 2005, the female host at that time was dignified and intellectual, and she was the only one who was as "crazy" as Xie Na.
In a sense, Xie Na can be regarded as the "pioneer".
But just being "crazy and funny" is not enough to make the audience hate her to this day, and there are more reasons.
Second, Xie Na's ability cannot match her status
Xie Na is a well-known host and the star with the most Weibo followers, up to 127 million, more than He Jiong.
The guest appearance fee of "Riding the Wind 2023" on the Internet, Xie Na topped the list of 33 sisters with a single issue of 1.8 million. Xie Na's "status in the rivers and lakes" cannot be described as low.
But Xie Na has acquired so many resources, wealth, has her ability to keep up?
As a host, Xie Na's professional ability has been questioned.
1. As the host of "Fast Ben", Xie Na always grabs the words and the camera, interrupts the guest speech, and does not pay attention to the guests' feelings. A few examples.
At that time, Huang Lei and Yan Ni participated in the show together, there was a guessing session, because Yan Ni was too shy, He Jiong kept guiding, hoping that Yan Ni could take the initiative to sing.
Just happened to meet a song that Yan Ni can sing, Huang Lei will also, according to the stage should be Huang Lei and Yan Ni singing together, because at that time they wanted to promote the movie "Dog's Eyes See People's Hearts".
But Xie Na didn't understand it at all, and when she heard the song, she rushed up to sing it, and didn't think about taking care of the guests at all.
Huang Zitao participated in the show and had a chorus session with Xie Na, but Xie Na sang the whole process, and Huang Zitao couldn't even interject. Even the flower characters of the program group couldn't help but match Huang Zitao with a wordless ellipsis.
Xie Na also had all kinds of inappropriate small actions such as pulling He Sui's hair and pinching Duoduo's neck, so I won't take stock of them one by one.
2. Hosting a large party is always a moth
Previously, Hunan Satellite TV's New Year's Eve party would definitely have Xie Na's figure, and the host manuscript was unfavorable, which was a trivial shortcoming for Xie Na.
In such a large-scale party, Xie Na did not change her true colors, she made trouble if she wanted to, and hit Du Haitao when she raised her hand in a dress.
When sharing the stage with the Tiantian brothers, Xie Na did not shy away from grabbing words, and the object of robbing words was Wang Han. He Jiong tapped her arm to remind her, and Xie Na didn't seem to notice.
In those years, every time Xie Na hosted the party, she would be on the hot search for "poor hosting ability".
3. Leaving He Jiong, Xie Na is difficult to pick a big beam
In 2016, Xie Na went to Oriental Satellite TV and hosted a talk show "Na Just Say So". After the broadcast, the bad reviews of the show were rave reviews, and Xie Na's shortcomings such as not taking the stem, not controlling the scene, and having no connotation were exposed.
In the end, the show received a low score of 4.5. Netizen comments: Talk shows need to have cultural connotations, and they can't be supported by gags alone.
This can't help but remind people of Huang Lei's evaluation of Xie Na: Your life is shallow. I have to say that "human essence" Huang Lei hits the nail on the head.
Third, Xie Na's character is full of controversy
In addition to being in a home venue like "Fast Ben", Xie Na will ignore the feelings of the guests, and she often shows an impolite side when she goes to other variety shows.
For example, when she went to "Longing for Life", she threatened in the car that "the mushroom house has changed owners and the house will be demolished."
After arriving at the recording location, I didn't expect that Xie Na really erased the three words of Mushroom House, and then wrote Xie House.
She borrowed money from Bao Wenjing in "Wife Travel", and did not pay it back at the first time, Bao Wenjing asked tactfully, but she raked upside down, saying that Bao Wenjing was stingy.
But when Wei Daxun owed her money, she would post small essays and "collect debts" on Weibo.
Xie Na was invited to participate in the recording of the charity ceremony together with He Jiong, Zeng Baoyi, and Sa Bening, and if Xie Na grabbed Zeng Baoyi on the stage, she saw that she couldn't grab it, so she directly took Zeng Baoyi's microphone.
After Sabine and Zeng Baoyi finished singing, they immediately belittled them: the singing was out of tune!
In the early years, Xie Na filmed with Jackie Chan's son, when Xie Na needed to hang Weiya on the roof, so only she wore Weiya clothes.
But when Xie Na took off, he kept grabbing Jackie Chan's son, but he didn't wear a Weiya suit, and he was always carried by Xie Na to the air, scared half to death.
In the end, it was the staff who put down Weiya, and Jackie Chan's son was saved.
In fact, what Xie Na did in this series is difficult to say whether it is out of sincerity or for the effect of variety shows. But she herself said that making shows is all out of instinct.
Is Xena a bad person? I think it must not be. For so many years, He Jiong is willing to always carry Xie Na, and the two are close friends and relatives.
Xie Na also has many friends in the circle, Zhao Liying, Chen Qiaoen, Yang Di, etc., who have known each other for many years and have maintained a good relationship.
It can only be said that Xie Na is not high in emotional intelligence in some aspects, has a little cleverness, but does not have a bad eye. Treat friends with sincerity enough.
Do the math, Xie Na has been in the industry for 27 years, her career has long reached its peak, and she has both fame and profit. If the audience still doesn't like her, presumably she won't change, and she doesn't have to change.
As Jiang Sida said to Xie Na in the interview show: If a person has everything, what will she change?