laitimes

The Kingdom of Shu perished, should Zhuge Liang be responsible

author:Small leaf of the motherland

I think of course Zhuge Chengxiang is not responsible!

The demise of the State of Shu is directly related to Liu Bei's arrogance in the later period and the random dispatch of troops! It is also directly related to Guan Yu's careless loss of Jingzhou and Zhang Fei's beating and scolding of the soldier being killed. If you have to ask Zhuge Liang, is he responsible? Then I think Zhuge Liang's responsibility is to slow down the speed of the demise of the Shu Kingdom.

The Kingdom of Shu perished, should Zhuge Liang be responsible

After Liu Bei won Jingzhou, Hanzhong, and Chengdu, it can be said that the world has accounted for the second place. There were five tiger generals, Guan Yu, Zhang Fei, Zhao Yun, Huang Zhong, Ma Chao and others, and the think tank also had the so-called outsmart Wolong Zhuge Liang and the phoenix Pang Tong. It can be said that Wen and the martial generals have reached their peak, Cao Cao and Sun Quan are no longer opponents, and only he can defeat Liu Bei.

Therefore, when Liu Bei's army attacked Wu, Sun Quan was eager to form an alliance with Cao Wei, which shows the huge power of Liu Bei at that time. But at this time, Liu Bei gradually lost himself, felt that his achievements were thousand, and his great cause would be accomplished, and he began to claim the emperor. The arrogant Guan Yu was mistakenly stationed in Jingzhou, when Sun Quan was forced by Liu Bei's power to let his son marry Guan Yu's daughter, which had achieved the goal of reconciliation with Eastern Wu. But Guan Yu actually said: The tiger girl Yan can marry a dog. What an arrogant remark this is, no matter how bad Sun Quan is, he is also a prince of one side, how can you allow a martial general to insult. It was Guan Yu's incomparable arrogance that led to his later being killed by Lü Meng and losing Jingzhou.

The Kingdom of Shu perished, should Zhuge Liang be responsible

After Guan Yu's death, Zhang Fei was also killed by soldiers for beating the soldiers, and sent the heads to Eastern Wu. Because of the tragic deaths of the two brothers, Liu Bei ignored the overall situation that Jingzhou had been lost and the war situation was seriously unfavorable, and did not listen to the good words and persuasion of Zhuge Liang and others, and insisted on attacking Sun Quan. And say that if there is no support, you cannot stand on your own. In the subsequent battle, he was proud and arrogant, regarded the talents of Jiangdong as grass mustard, indiscriminately used the art of war, set up camp in the woods, and was finally burned by Lu Xun's 700,000 army.

This fire burned Liu Bei's dream of unifying the whole country and restoring the Han Dynasty, and burned the soldiers, weapons, grain and grass and other key resources that he and Zhuge Liang had accumulated for decades, which directly led to the lack of national strength during Zhuge Liang's later Northern Expedition. It can be said that the loss of Jingzhou directly led to the demise of the Shu state.

The Kingdom of Shu perished, should Zhuge Liang be responsible

Zhuge Liang said that Han and thief are not opposed, and Wang Ye is not partial. This is because he is well aware of the great advantages of the land population of the Central Plains. If they had been stationed in Chengdu, they would sooner or later be annexed by Cao Wei's forces. That's why despite all objections, six out of Qishan, only for Cao Wei. Zhuge Liang often lamented in the later period, if Jingzhou is still there, why not. Although the later Northern Expedition caused labor and wealth to the people, it also dealt a heavy blow to the Cao Wei forces, making them dare not attack the Shu state in the short term, ensuring the peace of the Shu state for decades.

The Kingdom of Shu perished, should Zhuge Liang be responsible

It can be said that the demise of the Shu state was ultimately due to Liu Bei's misuse of his brothers Guan Yu and Zhang Fei. Guan Yu Zhang Fei's death lies in his character, one is too arrogant, the other is too irritable. It can be done, but it can also be bad. Liu Bei was also too arrogant in the later period, and defeated Lu Xun, completely destroying the hope of unifying the whole country.

Therefore, the responsibility for the demise of the Shu state lies with the three brothers Liu Guan and Zhang, not Zhuge Liang.