"Man Jiang Hong" sued netizens, which is gratifying, this is a win-win, and only Zhang Yimou may lose

On the evening of January 28, the official account of the movie "Manjiang Hong" released a message saying:

It's been a long time, and it's always coming.

Recently, some users fabricated false information about the movie "Manjiang Hong" through online platforms and spread it in large quantities, seriously endangering the legitimate rights and interests of the film, and now formally filed a lawsuit against the following rumor-mongers.

The Internet is not an illegal place, thank the audience for their support of this film.

After this news was issued, several parties who were "sued" also issued responses, welcoming the "prosecution" of the movie "Manjiang Hong" and actively responding to the lawsuit.

However, careful netizens found several problems. First, the movie "Manjiang Hong" sued netizens, the procedure was wrong, and the court may not accept it. Second, under the premise that the court has not accepted and decided for the time being, the movie "Manjiang Hong" claims that several netizens who have been "sued" are "rumor-mongers", which has constituted a personal insult, and several netizens who have been "sued" can counterclaim according to law.

Up to now, the remarks of several "sued" netizens about "Manjiang Red" can still be verified on social media platforms. Among the netizens who were "sued", some have sorted out all their remarks about "Manjiang Hong" for more netizens to view. Because these statements involve possible judicial proceedings, they will not be repeated in this article.

Regarding the movie "Manjiang Hong" suing netizens - it is important to note that here should be netizens, or media people, not rumor-mongers, before the court has not decided, it is believed that the media and individuals cannot be called "sued" are rumor-mongers, together, this article puts double quotation marks around the word "prosecution", really because the current behavior of the movie "Manjiang Hong" is a procedural error, and the court will not accept it in theory, so there is no prosecution - for the movie "Manjiang Hong" "suing" netizens, I think, It's a win-win situation.

The first to win, of course, is the movie "Manjiang Hong" itself. It is worth praising to protect one's own rights through "prosecution" in accordance with laws and regulations. This method of "prosecution" is always much more civilized and progressive than after some film and television dramas are released and premiered, after film critics and drama critics give bad reviews, they organize water armies to scold film critics and drama critics' ancestors for nineteen generations to be civilized and progressive. Safeguarding one's own rights in accordance with laws and regulations is very commendable.

Based on this, I hope that the rights holder of the movie "Manjiang Hong" must insist on suing, especially on the premise that the first "lawsuit" procedure error may be rejected by the court, and must improve its own procedures and truly enter the prosecution link. Defend your own rights, optimistic about you, little red red.

The second winner was several netizens who were "sued". Why did these netizens win? Because if these netizens are not the identity of the "defendants", they cannot apply to the court to verify all the contracts and bills of the movie "Manjiang Hong" in accordance with laws and regulations. If these netizens really become defendants in the end, then they asked a third party to intervene and verify all contracts, agreements and bills of the movie "Manjiang Hong" in accordance with laws and regulations, and there would be a legal basis.

Careful verification by a third party, and the final judgment of the court, will determine whether some of the rumors on the Internet are true or false. This is also very fair to several netizens who were "sued".

The third winner is the entire film critic cultural ecosystem. Writing a film review and being sued, somewhat uncomfortable for film critics. Before the movie "Manjiang Hong" sued netizens, the film was also exposed by film critics, and through platform complaints, they tried to remove the film critics' bad reviews of the movie "Manjiang Hong". So far, not a single film has been prosecuted for some "film critics" who brazenly wrote propaganda articles. However, there have been many film producers who have sued critics who write bad reviews of movies.

This time, "Manjiang Hong" sued netizens, if it is finally accepted, it will be a good thing for the entire film cultural ecosystem. Through this lawsuit, everyone should take a look at the boundaries of film reviews, what kind of film reviews can be written, and what kind of film reviews are illegal. At present, many filmmakers have sued film critics at every turn. And film critics can't make their true voices in addition to advocating movies without a bottom line? And what kind of critical voice is protected by law? It takes a lawsuit to tell everyone.

Before the win-win situation, the old editor sincerely hoped that the rights holders of the movie "Manjiang Hong" would not be instigated and must sue to the end. In addition to the three wins, only Zhang Yimou may lose. In the early years, director Chen Kaige clashed with film critics because of "A Bloody Case Caused by a Bun", and this "public case" has been recorded in the memories of fans. Obviously, this will be written into the history of cinema. This time, "Manjiang Hong" directed by Zhang Yimou, suing netizens, is a similar thing. This is to be written into the history of cinema.

In the movie "Manjiang Hong", Qin Hui is particularly afraid that Yue Fei's "Manjiang Hong" will be spread, because it means that he will be written into the pillar of shame in history - this is promoted by the film and does not match the official history. On the other hand, this movie "Manjiang Hong" sued netizens, is director Zhang Yimou afraid? Whether winning or losing, this "copywriting" can be regarded as entering the history of film. Zhang Yimou directs himself, do you feel glorious?

Out of love for director Zhang Yimou, I personally suggest that Director Zhang quickly clear up the relationship with the rights party of the movie "Manjiang Hong", and the prosecution is their (not an insulting word, but the right party itself is "it" attribute), director Zhang Yimou should at least express his position, support serious bad film reviews, support film critics to seriously watch the movie, and criticize the movie "Manjiang Hong". Otherwise, what would history say about Zhang Yimou? (Text/Ma Qingyun)